Fate of JetBlue-Spirit merger hangs in balance as antitrust trial begins

Becoming a member of forces to tackle the large gamers? Or chopping out competitors on the decrease ranges?

That is the query because the Division of Justice squares off with JetBlue and Spirit Airways in federal District courtroom.

The long-awaited trial over JetBlue and Spirit Airways’ deliberate merger started on Tuesday in Boston, setting the stage for a showdown that would resolve the long-term fates of each airways.

Need extra airline-specific information? Join TPG’s free biweekly Aviation e-newsletter.

Throughout opening statements, each the federal government and the airways laid out acquainted arguments towards and for the merger. The DOJ cited inner analyses from JetBlue that discovered {that a} mixed airline might have fares that had been 30% larger in some eventualities, and famous that even when there are just a few routes on which JetBlue and Spirit compete immediately, eliminating competitors on any routes must be sufficient to justify blocking the merger.

The federal government additional argued that it was unreasonable to count on different ULCCs like Allegiant to select up the aggressive mantle of Spirit, since these different carriers focus extra on unserved markets with out direct competitors from the legacy carriers.

JetBlue, however, repackaged an argument much like the one it introduced in the course of the Northeast Alliance (NEA) trial simply over a 12 months in the past — that the one method JetBlue can obtain sufficient scale to compete successfully towards the “Massive 4” airways could be by buying Spirit. By doing so, the mixed airline might be extra aggressive and convey fares down general throughout all markets.

As an additional apart, attorneys for the airways famous that Spirit had suffered growing monetary losses by attempting to compete in markets with the “legacy” airways by utilizing the ultra-low-cost-carrier (ULCC) enterprise mannequin, and certain might neither survive nor compete with out a change.

Whereas JetBlue’s argument is much like the one it deployed in final 12 months’s NEA trial, which it will definitely misplaced, the state of affairs now’s completely different. The NEA has been dissolved, and JetBlue is not speaking about partnering with a competitor; it is trying to actively purchase a smaller one with a special enterprise mannequin, successfully doubling its measurement in a single day.

Following opening statements, Spirit Airways CEO Ted Christie was referred to as by the DOJ as the primary witness, wrapping questioning shortly earlier than courtroom was adjourned for the day.

The federal government’s questions centered round Christie’s opposition to a JetBlue takeover throughout early discussions between the airways, as Spirit’s board was pushing for a merger with ULCC competitor Frontier Airways.

Regardless of Christie’s and the Spirit board’s desire, the airline’s shareholders had been enticed by the upper money provide made by JetBlue. In an effort to persuade them to vote for the Frontier merger as an alternative, Spirit’s board despatched a number of communications outlining why federal regulators would doubtless object to the merger with JetBlue.

In a single presentation, the board wrote that “at it is core, the JetBlue proposal represents a high-cost, high-fare airline shopping for a low-cost, low-fare airline, with half the synergies coming from diminished capacities and elevated fares.”

Different slides within the presentation provided feedback suggesting that “JetBlue has said it would scale back capability and lift fares on Spirit routes,” together with “Spirit continues to be a verify on JetBlue’s fares.”

Christie dismissed the communications as his views on the time, which he implied had since advanced.

The protection will query Christie on Wednesday morning.

The trial is scheduled to final over 20 enterprise days, with testimony every morning from consultants and different executives, together with JetBlue CEO Robin Hayes. A call from Senior District Choose William G. Younger is more likely to take months.

TPG is reporting from the U.S. District Courtroom in Boston, so keep tuned for the newest on the Spirit-JetBlue trial.