Apple CarPlay could be a trojan horse into the automotive industry

Apple is using the iPhone’s popularity to push itself into the auto industry. Automakers are a little unsure how they feel about this.

Apple announced the next generation of its car software CarPlay in June. It takes over the user interface on all interior screens, replacing gas gauges and speed dials with a digital version powered by the driver’s iPhone. It suggested CarPlay helps automakers sell vehicles.

Apple engineering manager Emily Schubert said 98% of new cars in the U.S. come with CarPlay installed. She delivered a shocking stat: 79% percent of U.S. buyers would only buy a car if it supported CarPlay.

“It’s a must-have feature when shopping for a new vehicle,” Schubert said during a presentation of the new features.

The auto industry faces an unappealing choice: Offer CarPlay and give up potential revenue and the chance to ride a major industry shift, or spend heavily to develop their own infotainment software and cater to an increasing audience of car buyers who won’t buy a new vehicle without CarPlay.

Carmakers sell additional services and features to car owners on a regular, recurring basis as cars connect to the internet, gain self-driving features, and move from being powered by gasoline to powered by electricity and batteries.

The car software market will grow 9% per year through 2030, faster than the overall auto industry, according to a McKinsey report. Car software could account for $50 billion in sales by 2030, McKinsey analysts predict.

Apple wants a piece of the pie.

GM, which wasn’t listed on Apple’s slide, already makes $2 billion per year in in-car subscription revenue and expects it to grow to $25 billion per year by 2030. Tesla, which doesn’t support CarPlay, recently shifted into selling its “FSD” driver assistance features, including auto-parking and lane keeping, as a subscription that costs as much $199 per month.

Automakers in China are starting to create electric vehicles that integrate deeply with their apps, allowing drivers to get repairs, connect with other owners, or even get their rented batteries replaced.

“We believe this could eventually lead to Apple providing services leveraging car sensor platforms,” Goldman Sachs analyst Rod Hall wrote in June about the next-generation CarPlay.

The next generation of CarPlay will need significant buy-in from automakers to give Apple’s software access to core systems. Apple suggested it secured cooperation from several major carmakers.

“Automakers around the world are excited to bring this new version of CarPlay to customers,” Schubert added before displaying a slide with 14 carmaker brands, including Ford, Mercedes-Benz and Audi.

Industry observers believe car-makers need to embrace software services — and look at Apple’s offering with skepticism — or risk getting left behind.

“It’s a really difficult time in the industry, where the car companies think they’re still building cars. They’re not. They’re building software on wheels, and they don’t know it, and they’re trading it away,” said Conrad Layson, senior analyst at AutoForecast Solutions.

The new version of CarPlay could be a huge new revenue engine for Apple.

First, if a user loves the iPhone’s CarPlay interface, then they’re less likely to switch to an Android phone. That’s a strategic priority for Apple, which generates the majority of its revenue through hardware sales.

Second, while the company doesn’t yet charge a fee to automakers or suppliers, it could sell services for vehicles the same way it distributes iPhone software.

In June, Apple revealed that it has explored features that integrate commerce into the car’s cockpit. One new feature announced this summer would allow CarPlay users to navigate to a gas pump and pay for the gas from the dashboard of the car, according to Reuters.

Apple already generates tens of billions from the App Store, and stands to boost that if it ever decides to charge for services in cars.

In 2021, for example, Apple grossed between $70 billion and $85 billion in total sales from its App Store — of which it takes between 15% and 30%, depending on the app. Apple doesn’t currently take a percentage of purchases made on iPhone apps for physical goods or services.

The new CarPlay also allows Apple to collect high-level knowledge and data about how people use their cars. That’s valuable information if it ever ends up releasing its own car, which has been under highly secretive development for years. (Apple’s car group and its CarPlay team are organized in separate divisions.)

For example, when users use Apple’s Maps app, the company gains insight into which routes are most popular and when traffic is highest. It’s also in a position to see which CarPlay apps are gaining traction and downloads.

In a note earlier this year, Morgan Stanley analysts surmised advances in self-driving could free up trillions of hours per year that Apple could address with new services and products — a potentially enormous market.

“What’s an hour of human time worth in a car with nothing to do? Depends who you ask… but (and this is just our view) 1.2 trillion hours times anything is A VERY LARGE NUMBER,” Morgan Stanley analysts wrote earlier this year.

Apple says heavy hitters like Honda, Nissan, and Renault are “excited” to support the new CarPlay. The 14 brands represented on Apple’s slide delivered over 17 million vehicles in 2021.

But car companies might not be as excited as Apple suggested. Few of them have announced models that will support the new CarPlay and most are non-committal.

Land Rover, which appeared on Apple’s slide, is “working with Apple” to see how they could be “part of” its infotainment system, a spokesperson said. “It is too early to comment on future product offerings,” the Land Rover and Jaguar spokesperson added.

Mercedes-Benz described its commitment to CarPlay as “discussions” with Apple.

“In general, we evaluate all potentially relevant new technologies and functions internally,” a Mercedes Benz spokesperson said.

The lack of commitment from automakers may be a timing and product cycle issue: Apple says that vehicles will start to be announced “late next year.” But the cool reaction could also be because the new CarPlay represents a major shift in Apple’s relationship with cars.

The new CarPlay will require the car’s real-time systems to pass that information back to the user’s iPhone, where it will be analyzed and integrated into Apple’s own software and rendered on the car’s screens. Apple’s interface will also include vehicle controls. Users can tap an Apple-designed touchscreen button to turn up the air conditioning, according to Apple’s promotional video.

“Gaining control of these root functions is notable because it effectively shifts the in-car experience from the hands of the carmaker over to Apple,” Loup Funds founder Gene Munster wrote in a research note.

Whether carmakers will give up that control over the in-car experience could be strategically critical for the auto industry. Savvy digital-first electric car makers such as Tesla and Rivian have eschewed Apple CarPlay, over the protests of their users, most likely for strategic reasons (although Apple CEO Tim Cook reportedly took a ride in a Rivian truck earlier this month.)

If in-car computers and screens end up primarily displaying Apple’s interface, then automakers will have less ability to sell those services to their customers. And they could lose the ability to define their customer relationship with online services and apps.

“The aim of the game has to be for the OEMs: ‘I must have a seat at the table somewhere such that when these services come in, I have a finger in the pie,” Radio Free Mobile analyst Richard Windsor said. “In order to do that, the user’s smartphone has to remain in his pocket when he gets in the vehicle. The minute he turns on CarPlay, or Android Auto, or Android Automotive, or anything else, the carmaker is in real trouble.”