The need to ensure tests are followed up, and
examinations and tests are undertaken to determine the
extent of an illness to support timely diagnosis and
management, was highlighted in a decision by Health and
Disability Commissioner Morag McDowell.
This case
concerns services provided to a man by a GP and medical
centre, relating to the diagnosis and management of his
kidney disease, until the man was diagnosed with Stage 4
kidney failure.
In her decision Ms McDowell found the
GP in breach of the Code of Health and Disability Services
Consumers’ Rights (the Code) for a number of deficiencies
in care provided to the man, which collectively represented
a failure to provide services with reasonable care and
skill. She also found the GP in breach of the Code for not
adequately informing the man of his deteriorating renal
function test results in a timely manner and the risk of
ongoing use of certain medication in the context of impaired
renal function.
Ms McDowell emphasised “the importance
of good communication and robust clinical
documentation”.
She considered that “a number of
oversights in the man’s care contributed to a delay in his
diagnosis with Stage 4 kidney disease”.
Ms McDowell
noted clinical advice received that “overall management of
the man’s renal disease, particularly the failure to
undertake appropriate investigations early on to enable
staging of the disease and an appropriate structured
management and surveillance plan, departed from accepted
practice to a moderate degree”.
“I accept that the
medical centre had appropriate policies in place at the time
of these events, and consider the errors made by the GP were
individual failings and do not indicate broader systems
issues at the medical centre.
“However, I have
identified some deficiencies in the medical centre’s
complaint management on this occasion,” says Ms
McDowell.
Ms McDowell recommended the GP provide a
written apology to the man and his family, and conduct an
audit to ensure clinical documentation is of an appropriate
standard according to the Medical Council of New Zealand
(MCNZ) practice guidelines. She also recommended MCNZ
consider whether a review of the GP’s competence is
warranted.
Ms McDowell further recommended the medical
centre provide a written apology to the man and his family,
conduct a further audit to ensure that patients are
classified appropriately in terms of whether they have
kidney disease, and undertake communication and complaints
management training for staff.
The medical centre
accepted the findings of this report, and following the
events of this case undertook a range of actions and made
changes to improve its processes and policies. HDC were also
advised by the GP that he has reflected on, and learnt from
this complaint, and made changes to his systems and
practice.
“Complaints provide a learning opportunity
which can lead to system improvements. I am pleased to see
the changes made since these events by the GP and medical
centre, which will result in improved standards of care and
may prevent other families going through a similar situation
in the future,” says Ms
McDowell.
© Scoop Media



















Discussion about this post