• Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe Now
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Philadelphia Eagles Facing Turmoil as Coach Nick Sirianni Addresses Controversy Over Gesture to Fans

    Philadelphia Eagles Facing Turmoil as Coach Nick Sirianni Addresses Controversy Over Gesture to Fans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
The Insight Post
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Philadelphia Eagles Facing Turmoil as Coach Nick Sirianni Addresses Controversy Over Gesture to Fans

    Philadelphia Eagles Facing Turmoil as Coach Nick Sirianni Addresses Controversy Over Gesture to Fans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home North America Canada

‘Flawed’ findings on lockdowns fed province’s decision to end mandates

by Theinsightpost
August 18, 2022
in Canada
0 0
0
‘Flawed’ findings on lockdowns fed province’s decision to end mandates


The New Brunswick Department of Health’s March 2022 decision to end mask mandates and other COVID-19 measures was made after officials circulated an academic paper widely criticized as “fundamentally flawed.”

The paper, by three researchers tied to libertarian think-tanks, concluded that lockdowns did not significantly reduce the death rate during the first wave of COVID-19 in early 2020.

But the study, a so-called “meta-analysis” that synthesizes dozens of individual studies, is full of problems, according to other researchers. 

“The study has some methodological issues which make the conclusion just not reliable. So there’s a high risk of potential bias,” says Adrian Lison, a doctoral student and infectious disease researcher at ETH Zurich.

“And as the study is not yet peer-reviewed, we think it does not really add reliable new insights to the body of knowledge, so we recommend to not use the quite strong conclusions in this review in policy.”

The paper was circulating among New Brunswick Department of Health officials in early February. It has not been published in an academic journal.

Since the study is not yet peer-reviewed, Adrian Lison, an infectious disease researcher, recommends that it not be used to review policy. (Submitted by Adrian Lison)

Lockdowns “have had little to no public health effects” but enormous economic costs, it says. They are “ill-founded and should be rejected as a pandemic policy instrument.”

Health Department spokesperson Adam Bowie said officials review data “from many different studies” as well as from epidemiologists in the province when making decisions. 

“A recommendation from Public Health to introduce or remove any health mandate would never be based on any one study or report,” he said.

The meta-analysis “would have only been one source of information under consideration,” he said, though he didn’t identify any other studies they used.

Kathleen Gadd of the pro-mandate citizens’ group Protect our Province, which obtained the study through a right-to-information request, says it was the only so-called academic research the province handed over.

“The fact that they didn’t supply any other papers says a lot,” she said.

“If other studies and peer-reviewed papers and evidence were used to inform the lifting of the mandatory order, this would have been the time to supply the public with that information.” 

The Department of Health did not respond to a request for an interview on what role the paper played in the mandate decision.

Use of broad term ‘lockdown’ is ‘dangerous,’ researcher says

Among the flaws identified by critics is the paper’s use of the general term “lockdown” for a range of policies from stay-at-home orders to mask mandates. 

That makes measuring the impact of individual restrictions difficult, says Lison, who co-authored a rebuttal posted to the Social Science Research Network website.

He says it’s “dangerous in a systematic review to use such a broad term, because if you make conclusions in the end, there’s a high risk that people will misinterpret your findings.” 

The paper also measures death rates without looking at other impacts, such as reduced transmission and a reduced impact of hospitalizations on the heath care system.

Lison says transmission is a better measure of lockdown impacts because it’s most directly affected by restrictions, whereas hospitalization and death happens after a delay. 

Health official called paper’s conclusions ‘interesting’ 

The province lifted its mandatory COVID-19 order on March 14, ending mask mandates, proof-of-vaccination requirements and limits on gatherings.

The 60-page paper, “A Literature Review and Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Lockdowns on Covid-19 Mortality,” was the only research study included in the 200 pages turned over to the PoP group when it asked for documents relating to the decision.

In a Feb. 4, 2022 email, Nina van der Pluijm, the director of well-being, legislation and standards at the department, sent the study to several colleagues, remarking, “Interesting info re: lock-down effectiveness.”

She noted its conclusion that the average lockdown had reduced mortality by only 0.2 percent. 

Gadd, a former health sciences librarian, says “quite a number” of people with expertise at universities and health authorities could have supplied officials with better studies.

“There’s no sign that information professionals, such as health science librarians, were engaged in these quite significant decisions that were made regarding the health of New Brunswickers,” she said.

“There’s a large amount of peer-reviewed, high-quality evidence that has been completely ignored by those in power regarding how to manage the pandemic.” 

Paper criticized as ‘unbalanced’ for excluding other studies

The meta-analysis, published in January, synthesizes the findings of 34 separate studies. The authors began with hundreds of studies but screened out most of them.

“Unfortunately this review has only focused on a very small subset of analysis … and has excluded a large part of the overall body evidence, the overall epidemiological research, so it is also rather unbalanced,” Lison said.

Dr. Seth Flaxman, a computer science professor at the University of Oxford, called the meta-analysis “fundamentally flawed” for excluding studies rooted in epidemiology.

Researchers at Imperial College in London said in June 2020 that lockdowns in the first wave of the pandemic probably averted 3.1 million deaths in 11 European countries. 

New Brunswick lifted its mandatory COVID-19 order on March 14, ending mask mandates, proof-of-vaccination requirements and limits on gatherings. (Evan Mitsui/CBC)

Another study estimated that lockdowns in six countries, including the U.S. and China, prevented or delayed 530 million cases of COVID-19.

“It is just problematic to exclude a majority of the research that is available, and it risks your review becoming very unbalanced and not representative,” Lison said.

“There are still of course some uncertainty and a lot of open questions, but there’s already substantial evidence on the effectiveness of interventions overall.” 

Authors tied to libertarian think-tanks

The authors are not epidemiologists or public health experts, and PoP has highlighted their connections to libertarian think-tanks opposed to most government interventions in society.

“The authors don’t represent the fields of study that are applicable to epidemiology, public health, disease transmission, those kinds of fields that we should be looking to for information around our pandemic response,” Gadd said.

Co-author Jonas Herby, an economist at the Centre for Political Studies in Copenhagen, Denmark, is a contributor to the American Institute for Economic Research, which bills itself as promoting “pure freedom and private governance,” with government “sharply confined.”

Another co-author, Steve Hanke, is a fellow at the right-wing Cato Institute who has referred to lockdowns and mandates as “cracking the fascist whip.”

Jonas Herby, a co-author of the paper, says most of the ‘curve flattening’ of COVID deaths early in the pandemic was due to voluntary distancing, not lockdown requirements. (CBC)

In an interview, Herby acknowledged the conservative leanings of the authors and said that shaped the question they wanted to pose in the paper. But their research method was sound, he added.

He said the meta-analysis focused on deaths because there were not many studies available on hospitalizations.

On criticism that the authors used the broad term “lockdown” for a range of different restrictions, Herby said that’s why the reduction in mortality of 0.2 per cent is based on an “average” lockdown.

“I think it’s bad science to say your science is bad just because you have a different political view than I have.” 

Revised version shows larger reduction in deaths

The paper’s three authors published a revised version in May.

It recalculates the reduction in death caused by lockdowns as 3.2 percent – still lower than other studies, but 16 times higher than the 0.2 percent estimate in the first version.

Mask mandates had the largest effect, reducing COVID-19 mortality by 18.7 percent, it says.

The authors say what matters  is not particular figures but the fact the number of lives saved by lockdowns “are much smaller and far removed” from what epidemiologists, politicians and the media promised.

Most of the “curve flattening” of COVID deaths early in the pandemic was due to voluntary distancing, not lockdown requirements, Herby says.

People changed their behaviour of their own free will in response to a threat, he says.

“The question is can lockdowns enhance this behaviour change? I think they can, but the effect is very limited.” 

The new version includes a statement that it “does not imply that lockdowns do not work.

“It simply indicates that the most lenient lockdowns had virtually the same effect on mortality as stricter lockdowns. Since no country did nothing, we cannot reject the thesis that some NPI would be required, e.g., to spur voluntary behavioral changes.”

Lison said he found the authors’ defence of the meta-analysis “largely not convincing” and said the revised version did not change his view that the paper should not be used by governments as policy advice.

“Most problems of the first version remain,” he said.



Source link

ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Piper Sandler says buy Freshpet as the stock can surge more than 45% on strong growth

Next Post

Helping business flow – Digicloud Africa’s Gregory MacLennan discusses digital natives and Google Cloud

Related News

Oilers Deliver Impressive Victory Over Leafs in Thrilling Matchup
Canada

Oilers Deliver Impressive Victory Over Leafs in Thrilling Matchup

November 15, 2026
Tragedy Strikes in Burlington: Three Children and Two Adults Hospitalized Following Devastating House Fire, Say Halton Police
Canada

Tragedy Strikes in Burlington: Three Children and Two Adults Hospitalized Following Devastating House Fire, Say Halton Police

November 14, 2026
Suspect Sought in Assault and Theft Incident in Annex
Canada

Suspect Sought in Assault and Theft Incident in Annex

November 13, 2026
Ebenezer Review: Is Johnny Depp’s Christmas Tale the Start of His Comeback?
Canada

Ebenezer Review: Is Johnny Depp’s Christmas Tale the Start of His Comeback?

November 13, 2026
Next Post
Helping business flow – Digicloud Africa’s Gregory MacLennan discusses digital natives and Google Cloud

Helping business flow – Digicloud Africa’s Gregory MacLennan discusses digital natives and Google Cloud

Discussion about this post

Subscribe To Our Newsletters

    Customer Support


    1251 Wilcrest Drive
    Houston, Texas
    77042 USA
    Call-832.795.1420
    e-mail – news@theinsightpost.com

    Subscribe To Our Newsletters

      Categories

      • Africa
      • Africa-East
      • African Sports
      • American Sports
      • Arts
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • Business
      • Business Asia
      • Business- Africa
      • Canada
      • Defense
      • Education
      • Egypt
      • Energy
      • Entertainment
      • Europe
      • European Soccer
      • Finance
      • Germany
      • Ghana
      • Health
      • Insight
      • International
      • Investing
      • Japan
      • Latest Headlines
      • Life & Living
      • Markets
      • Mobile
      • Movies
      • New Zealand
      • Nigeria
      • Politics
      • Scholarships
      • Science
      • South Africa
      • South America
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • Travel-Africa
      • UK
      • USA
      • Weather
      • World
      No Result
      View All Result

      Recent News

      Gators Shock Wildcats 21-14 in Thrilling Upset Amid Rollercoaster Season

      Gators Shock Wildcats 21-14 in Thrilling Upset Amid Rollercoaster Season

      November 15, 2026
      Government Announces Historic  Billion Investment in Energy Infrastructure Development

      Government Announces Historic $2 Billion Investment in Energy Infrastructure Development

      November 15, 2026
      Notre Dame Postgame Insights: Dive into Superchats with Westwood One Sports

      Notre Dame Postgame Insights: Dive into Superchats with Westwood One Sports

      November 15, 2026
      Transform Your Laptop Setup with These 5 Affordable Accessories

      Transform Your Laptop Setup with These 5 Affordable Accessories

      November 15, 2026
      • Home
      • Advertise With Us
      • About Us
      • Corporate
      • Consumer Rewards
      • Forum
      • Privacy Policy
      • Social Trends

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In

      Add New Playlist

      We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

      You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in .

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Insight
      • Blog
      • Business
      • Entertainment
      • Health
      • Politics
      • Shop
        • Gift Shop
        • Value Shop
        • Store
        • Bargain Shop
        • Discount
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • USA
      • Video
      • World
        • Asia
        • Africa
        • South America
        • North America
        • Europe
        • Oceania

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      The Insight Post
      Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

      Strictly Necessary Cookies

      Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

      Cookie Policy

      More information about our Cookie Policy