Period-tracking apps are popular digital tools for a
range of menstrual, reproductive and general health
purposes. But the way these apps collect and use data
involves risk.
Many apps encourage users to log
information well beyond their menstrual cycle, including
sexual activity, medications, sleep quality, exercise,
social activity and perimenopause symptoms. As well as this
logged data, apps often collect location and other
personally identifiable information.
Period tracking
apps may pose a particularly high risk in places where
abortion is illegal because user data may be accessed by law
enforcement on request.
Our new
research examines how aware app users in Aotearoa New
Zealand are of these risks. We found a range of levels of
understanding and perspectives on risk, from untroubled to
concerned and deeply worried about the implications of
digital tracking for reproductive rights.
Privacy,
data and risk
The first period-tracking app was released in
2013. Since then, hundreds
of such apps have been created, with collectively hundreds
of millions of downloads worldwide.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
A recent
analysis found app downloads are particularly prevalent
in North America, Europe, Australia and Aotearoa. The same
study found three apps – Flo, Clue and Period Tracker –
make up the majority of downloads.
Some period apps
can link to and import information from other apps and
wearables. For example, Clue can link
to and import information from the Oura
smart ring and Apple Health, both of which gather
personal health metrics. Flo can similarly import
information from other
health apps.
A recent
analysis of period app privacy policies found they often
collect a range of personally identifiable
information.
Personal health data flows to third
parties
Some participants in our research have used
an app for a decade or longer. This means the app holds a
comprehensive database of years of intimate health data and
other personal information, including some which they may
not have chosen to provide.
This data can be used by a
range of third parties in commercial, research or other
applications, sometimes without app users’ explicit
knowledge or consent. One
study found many period apps exported more data than was
declared in privacy policies, including to third
parties.
Another
study reported that apps changed privacy policies
without obtaining user consent. Apps can also infer
sensitive information not explicitly logged by users by
combining data.
In 2021, Flo
reached a settlement with the US Federal Trade
Commission on charges over its sharing of user data with
marketing and analytics companies without user
consent.
App privacy
policies often state that user data may be accessed by
law enforcement on request, which is a major concern in
places where abortion is illegal. Users may explicitly log
the start and end of pregnancies, but pregnancy can also
be inferred or
predicted using other data. In some cases, period app
data may therefore reveal a user’s miscarriage or
abortion.
Making sense of the risk in New
Zealand
Our exploration of user attitudes about the
risk of period-tracking apps has revealed that about half of
participants were unconcerned about their data. Some
imagined positive uses for their data, such as improving the
app or contributing to reproductive healthcare research.
These potential
uses are often highlighted by period-tracking apps in
marketing materials.
Other participants were concerned
about their data. Some had risk minimisation strategies,
including limiting what information they logged. Concerned
participants were often resigned to uncontrolled uses of
their data.
One said:
[there’s] no
such thing as private data these
days.
Another thought
that:
everyone that does anything online
[…] is kind of accepting the fact that your data is being
potentially accessed and used by third parties. It’s just
kind of where it is now.
About a third of
participants in our study contextualised their concerns with
respect to reproductive rights and abortion access,
especially since the
2022 overturn of Roe v Wade in the US.
Others
wondered if what happened in the US could happen in New
Zealand. One participant referenced concepts such as
rangatiratanga and mana motuhake (self determination) when
thinking about period app data. She
said:
I worry about the politics that
happen overseas coming here to Aotearoa […] knowing that I
don’t have full control or rangatiratanga over the data I
provide. I worry for all users about what this
information can be used for in future, as much as we like to
say ‘this is New Zealand, that would never happen here’,
we have no idea.
With gender
and reproductive
rights at risk around the world, such concerns are
reasonable and justified.
Study participants used
period-tracking apps for diverse reasons, including to plan
for periods, to track pain and communicate it to doctors, to
help get pregnant, and to learn about their bodies. Some
participants told us that using period apps was empowering.
Some perceived period apps as risky, with limits to how they
can mitigate the risk.
Menstruators shouldn’t have
to trade data privacy and security in order to access the
benefits of period-tracking apps. Legislators and policy
makers should understand the benefits and risks and ensure
strong data protections are in place.
Anna
Friedlander, PhD Candidate in Sociology, University
of Waikato; Charlotte
Greenhalgh, Senior Lecturer in History, University
of Waikato; Holly
Thorpe, Professor in Sociology of Sport and
Gender, University
of Waikato, and Johanna
Schmidt, Teaching Fellow in Sociology, University
of Waikato
This article is republished from
The
Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
Read the original
article.
© Scoop Media



















Discussion about this post