Five minutes into the final quarter at the MCG, Collingwood’s season was in tatters.
Ladder-leaders and clear premiership favourites a mere six weeks ago, the Magpies’ dire form slump to end the home-and-away season looked set to hit a new low, courtesy of a messy but infinitely plucky performance from a Melbourne team who had capitalised on their opponents’ wretched inaccuracy in the first half to take a stranglehold on the game.
The Demons were 15 points to the good with all the momentum, and utter dominance in all facets of the game, when Christian Petracca nailed his set shot to begin the term.
The Pies, meanwhile, seemed out of ideas: squandering set shots, usually reliable kicks sending passes out on the full, and the surest sign of all – Nick Daicos giving away a free kick for high contact, then compounding the error with a 50m penalty after, you’d guess, assuming the whistle was for him.
With mounting injuries – Jeremy Howe subbed out with a groin injury, Brody Mihocek and Beau McCreery playing through the pain – the 2023 premiers were on the canvas, even with their September spot secure.
This is the story of 20 magic minutes that brought Collingwood’s season back from the brink – and serve as proof that , this Magpies team is a dangerous prospect once they freshen up from a week off and attack September as genuine underdogs … especially now that, thanks to Gold Coast’s loss, is all but theirs.
It’s a hint as well that, after repeated narrow losses over the last month and a half, the close game kings still have a shot to fire if any match this finals series goes down to the wire with them in it.
The first sign that this contest is far from over comes with a little over 12 minutes remaining, and features the facet that appeared to have deserted the Pies in the second half of 2025: Lady Luck.
Winning a boundary throw-in stoppage with a series of sharp handpasses to move the pressure from player to player, Ned Long, the star of the first half of the season whose form has perfectly mirrored that of his team in later stages, takes an ambitious snap from the boundary line that wobbles to the goalsquare.
Off the boot, it looks for all the world another squandered chance: set to bounce in the goalsquare, with Steven May only needing to get a fist to the footy to send it over the line.
Instead, the ball dips, and May suddenly finds himself desperately needing to make ground to get to it. And as Mihocek does his best to hold him off, the oval-shaped ball, with a mind of its own, decides it wants to make the black and white faithful smile.
Suddenly, a change is in the air: everyone in the crowd can feel it, everyone on the playing field can feel it, and presumably everyone watching at home feels it too.
Certainly, you can almost see Demon pulses begin to quicken and nerves start to tighten – with a chance to lower his eyes and pinpoint a target, Christian Salem instead blazes ineffectually for a rushed behind; moments later, a free Trent Rivers bursts inside 50, only for inaccuracy, having unexpectedly gone Melbourne’s way up until now, to strike at the worst time.
But this isn’t a story of how the Demons lost this game. It’s the story of how the Pies won it.
From the kick-in after Rivers’ behind, the Magpies find the magic that powered them through close game after close game in the early years of Craig McRae’s tenure. They go for the jugular.
Jack Crisp’s kick is straight through the middle, to a free Billy Frampton – an unlikely source to drive the Pies forward, but one borne of a speedy kick-in and a hole left through the corridor by Pies swarming to either flank.
From there, Frampton doesn’t worry about finesse – he bangs the ball as long as he possibly can, sending the footy to half-forward at a stroke, where McCreery, injured ankle and all, produces the effort that proves beyond all doubt why he is so crucial to the Magpies’ premiership hopes.
Having appeared done at three quarter time, McCreery keeps his feet and holds his ground as Salem jostles with him; then, with fleet feet as if his ankle hadn’t been badly rolled earlier in the match, he pivots, following the bouncing ball as it whistles by them, and in a stroke has two clear metres.
His kick inside 50 is a beauty, too – for not the first time and certainly not the last, McCreery laces out Jamie Elliott, on a hard lead into the pocket at a speed Steven May can’t hope to match.
Four kicks from end to end. Another goal. And suddenly, with ten minutes exactly remaining, the margin is four points. And Collingwood have closed, to echo Gerard Whateley’s famous call of THAT comeback against Carlton three years ago, like the Grim Reaper.
Amid a suddenly frenetic finish, the Dees continue to squander their chances – a flying Jacob van Rooyen snap from a scrimmage 20 metres out directly in front sails awry. But more concerning is the panic beginning to descend on a backline that has hitherto held firm against a superior opponent.
Nine minutes and 15 seconds remain when Lachie Schultz bombs inside 50, and we see the first sign of the nerves fraying in red and blue jumpers. Running back with the flight, but perfectly placed for an uncontested mark, Daniel Turner, for reasons known only to himself, decides to not only put a fist through the ball, but direct it at the worst possible spot – across the face and out of bounds for a throw-in.
He’s lucky to not pay full price when, from the resumption, a quick Lachie Schultz snap at goal fails to carry the distance and is marked by May in the goalsquare. But the woes are far from done.
The Pies in this position have been daring, bold, ambitious – everything a side chasing the game needs to be. But the Dees, in contrast, have been slow, beleaguered, predictable … and critically so.
May’s first mistake is the sideways chip across goal to Turner, who duly hands the ball straight back to May, giving the Pies time to close all gaps, tighten the screws, and force a long kick to a contest.
May, though, instead thinks he can see an escape, and falls right into the black and white trap. With Christian Petracca screaming for the ball at half-back, the veteran aims a kick in his direction … and fails to clear the Magpie zone, with Steele Sidebottom chipping in for the intercept mark.
Unlike May, Sidebottom wastes no time: quickly behind his mark, he centres into a cluster of Pies, with Schultz given a free lane by Jordan De Goey to mark without hassle.
It’s no certainty, especially given the Pies’ horrendous kicking for goal all night, but the former Docker makes no mistake. And the Magpies, somehow, from somewhere, are in front.
And still the Dees squander their chances: a long-range shot from the quiet Kysaiah Pickett is dragged left, briefly tying the scores before McCreery equalises at the other end to restore the Magpie lead.
But the Pies are irrepressible: after Scott Pendlebury intercepts at half-back, he again finds Melbourne’s structure ahead of the ball in a barely believable state of disarray. Having kicked long from defensive 50 to start the play, how has it come to be that no Demon is in sight of Roan Steele on the half-forward line? And why are only two Demons there to fly against Dan McStay for an inside 50 mark with the game on the line?
It’s another Pies goal, their fourth in a row, and establishes a seven-point lead. And from 7.15 to start the sequence, four of five shots at goal have sailed through the middle.
The Demons now are the ones needing to pull a rabbit out of the hat. The Pies? Unlike against Adelaide last week, a match that is theirs to save and not to snatch.
They look a chance when a free kick from the centre bounce allows Christian Petracca to drive them inside 50, but the Pies will prove hard to shake – the sight of Clayton Oliver in an inch of space inside 50 looking to fend off Pendlebury, only for the oldest body in the game to cling to him like a barnacle on a ship for a holding the ball free kick, speaks volumes for the state of both men’s careers.
The Dees have recovered their spark, though – perhaps too little too late – and as the clock ticks under four minutes, surge the footy down the wing and inside 50 with the handball game that defined their third-quarter storming into the lead.
Handball after handball after handball until finally, with the ball in the forward pocket, Petracca aims one more to the tip of the goalsquare. Up goes sub Harry Sharp to claim it … and down he comes in a crunching, brutal, goal-saving tackle from Darcy Cameron, with all the fatigue of tussling with the great Max Gawn from pillar to post.
Often this season, Cameron has saved the day with a telling intercept mark in defensive 50 – this is just as precious.
From the stoppage, Petracca makes it interesting, with a snap missing – another Dees behind, but one that reduces the margin to a straight kick. Every result is on the table now.
But there is yet more symbolism to come: as the Demons turn the ball over on the edge of 50 and march inside again, it’s of course Gawn on the end of the Bayley Fritsch handball, with the goals in his sights. The man who has done it all for his football club against near-insurmountable odds throughout this season.
So often has he defied what normal ruckman are meant to do that it’s a shock when he reverts to type here, and kicks it out on the full.
It’s a miss mirrored by Langdon a minute later, who snaps wildly from 30 metres out under heavy duress and strikes the behind post on the full. Lady Luck, it seems, is still smiling on the Magpies.
The Dees give themselves one more chance: Picket snaps the ball long inside 50, once again testing the Pies’ defence already missing Howe, as the clock ticks beneath 40 seconds.
From nowhere as the ball tumbles to ground amid a throng of black, white, red and blue, Brayden Maynard emerges from the contest with ball, somehow, in hand. He gives to Cameron, who with nothing else on the table, kicks the ball long, high and strong, and hopes.
Underneath it, Jack Crisp marks. The Pies will hold on – a fact confirmed when, from one last Dees burst as the clock ticks down to zero, Lachie Schultz runs down Tom Sparrow as the siren sounds.
The Pies have lost their close game crown this year. The Demons, meanwhile, are as far from clutch as any team in recent memory has been, with six losses from six games decided by single-figure margins.
Maybe it will mean nothing when September rolls around. But if there’s one thing we’ve learned over the last three years, it’s that a Collingwood with belief is a very, very, very dangerous proposition.



















Discussion about this post