ABA Accreditation Council Votes to Change First-Year Faculty Requirement
The American Bar Association’s (ABA) accreditation council has decided to eliminate a longstanding requirement that law schools must have full-time faculty teach the majority of first-year classes. This significant change comes after months of deliberation and external pressure from the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), which had warned of potential antitrust investigations if the council maintained the existing standard.
Background on the Decision
The vote to revise the faculty requirement took place last week and reflects an ongoing examination of the ABA’s accreditation policies. The DOJ’s concerns were highlighted in an October letter from Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, who argued that the existing mandate could lead to inflated costs for law schools and adversely affect students. Woodward indicated that allowing adjunct faculty to play a larger role could enhance educational quality while reducing expenses.
Before the changes are officially implemented, the ABA’s House of Delegates will review the proposal at their next meeting scheduled for February. Following this, the accreditation council will have the authority to finalize the decision.
Implications and Reactions
The council’s resolution has elicited mixed responses from the legal education community. While some institutions and faculty members express concern regarding the impact on the quality of legal education, others advocate for the increased flexibility in hiring practices. Notably, the faculty leadership at the University of Colorado Boulder’s law school opposed the change, emphasizing the critical role full-time faculty play in guiding students during their foundational year.
In their public comments, the Boulder faculty articulated that the first year is essential for instilling core legal principles and fostering community among students. They highlighted that full-time faculty are more accessible for student inquiries and possess the necessary expertise for effective course design and evaluation.
Conversely, proponents of the change, such as Terence Lau, dean of Syracuse University’s law school, argue that the revised policy would alleviate undue burdens on law schools. Lau noted that the current standard restricts the opportunity to engage experienced legal practitioners, such as judges or emeritus professors, in first-year instruction.
Ongoing Oversight and Future Steps
The ABA’s accreditation council is currently under scrutiny from federal authorities, particularly following a report from the U.S. Department of Education that recommended revoking the council’s federal recognition due to non-compliance with various federal standards. This recognition is crucial, as it allows the council to serve as a gatekeeper for Title IV financial aid. Although only a small number of accredited law schools rely on this for federal aid, the implications of losing federal recognition could be significant.
The panel advising the Education Department on accreditation matters recently deadlocked on a vote regarding the council’s recognition status, leaving the final decision pending from Education Under Secretary Nicholas Kent.
This latest development in the ABA’s accreditation standards reflects a broader conversation about the evolving landscape of legal education and its adaptation to contemporary challenges.


















Discussion about this post