Liberal Bridget Archer rises in support of the censure motion
The Liberal MP for Bass says it is not an attack on the three years of Scott Morrison’s leadership, but “rather a reflection on the specific actions taken, that in my view, defy the expectations we have for our leaders”.
As Virginia Bell concluded in her report, the actions taken were corrosive to trust in politics. Those actions sit outside the expectations of the Australian people. And it sits outside of how we expect elected representatives in the highest office to act.
I’ve relentlessly advocated for more integrity in politics and fought for an integrity commission that would begin to restore the public’s faith. In elected officials. To sit quietly now would be hypocritical and I firmly believe we should be intentional in the actions we take to ensure that we do not let this happen again.
Key events
Filters BETA
Anthony Albanese has asked for extra time to continue speaking here. He has gone from being unsure if he would speak to taking up two slots. And he is doing most of it off the cuff.
People had a responsibility to act. They didn’t.
It was a slippery slope that undermined the functioning of this parliament. That undermined our democratic institutions, that this House has a responsibility to act on.
I think that the comments of the member for New England go, in his own words, to motivation why people didn’t speak up.
I know that there’s a range of different contexts.
I’ve spoken about arrangements that were entered into that were not transparent.
I was asked a question this week about the discussions I had with Senator Pocock, and asked to be transparent about it. And I have been, as has Senator Pocock.
These things are important. It’s actually how our democracy functions. I cannot still conceive of the idea that, and this is why questions weren’t asked, because it’s impossible to conceive that a prime minister does not have the authority to have influence over their ministers. I hope I do!
At the end of the day, I have that great honour of leading this quite extraordinary group of ministers that have been sworn in. I assure you, I have not thought for a millisecond about being sworn in in order to override them.
Anthony Albanese: former deputy PM ‘should never have been asked to be put in that position’
He came up with a different explanation today. If only he was asked! To blame the media and everyone else. Why didn’t we come in here and ask if he’d been sworn in as treasurer or finance minister?
What’s your day job?
It’s just beyond comprehension that this parliament should be as a whole standing up and voting for this motion. The whole parliament. Because it began with measures like the former deputy prime minister, who I have a lot of respect for, and he knows that.
… The former deputy prime minister was told by the prime minister’s office then to not be transparent about whether he was acting prime minister in 2019.
That is how these things begin.
And I don’t blame the former deputy prime minister for being loyal to his prime minister. I respect that.
But he should never have been asked to be put in that position.
Nor should there have been a cabinet committee of one.
Nor should those people who were aware of this not declare it. The former deputy prime minister, the second one, former deputy prime minister, Barnaby Joyce, was asked on Insiders why it was that he was aware of the Pep 11 decision and why he did not speak up and say something about this at the time.
This was his response, and I quote:
‘I had negotiated an extra minister, which we were not entitled to. I had another person on the ERC which we were not entitled to. I negotiated more staff for the National party, which we were not entitled to. If I pursued this, it was quite simple – he just took away the portfolio that we weren’t entitled to and took us back to the number we were entitled to. He would have the portfolio back and we lose all power on August 21, 2022.’
Anthony Albanese: ‘This is not a one-man show’
This morning, I came here not certain as to whether I would speak.
But I have to respond to the prime minister’s comments, who has confirmed again that he just doesn’t get it, the former prime minister.
He said this morning that he had conversations privately with my colleagues.
It’s not about Josh Frydenberg. It’s about the people of Australia. That’s who we’re accountable to.
Through this parliament, at this dispatch box, we ask questions about Pep 11. We asked questions about health.
Not knowing that the then prime minister was actually responsible and sworn in.
The former prime minister flipped more questions to ministers than all previous 29 prime ministers.
The former prime minister shut down debate at this dispatch box each and every time where people attempted to make [enquiries] about the serious matters.
And when it goes to Covid, I had that sense too, as the leader of the opposition, which is why we on this side of the House now, when we sat there, took responsible decisions to not play politics, to vote for and to declare in advance of packages coming forward, that even if our amendments were not successful, even if there were measures which we did not agree with, such as the raiding of superannuation, we would not stand in the way.
Even though there was a political cost to that, that they were conscious of.
But we understood our obligation to the national interest. This is not a one man show.
This was the Australian people who stood up and protected themselves, not just in the parliament.
Those people who stayed at home, people who got vaccinated, the heroes of the pandemic who went out there and worked with people who were sick.
So all of this self-congratulation that we heard this morning should be dismissed.
Anthony Albanese: Morrison ‘was not responsible to the parliament and through that to the electors’
The fact is that our democracy is precious. There’s no room for complacency. We’ve seen overseas, including with the assault on the Capitol building in the United States, that we can’t take our democracy for granted.
The explanations that were put forward were described by Ms Bell as, ‘Not easy to understand and difficult to reconcile with the facts’.
The implications were there in the Bell inquiry. There was a risk of conflict if different ministers wanted to exercise the same power inconsistently.
Ms Bell confirmed the solicitor general’s view that it was fundamentally undermined because the member for Cook, the then prime minister, was not responsible to the parliament and through that to the electors for which he was appointed to administer. It undermined public confidence in government.
It was, according to Ms Bell, ‘corrosive of trust in government’.
The public didn’t know something it was entitled to know.
Anthony Albanese: censure motion ‘a profoundly sad moment’
A censure motion like this is as rare as it is grave. The fact that it has become so necessary constitutes a profoundly sad moment in the life of our national parliament.
But to ignore it would be to be complicit to say – well, that was OK. This House of Representatives has a responsibility. To declare its view on what occurred with these extraordinary actions by the former prime minister.
I wake up every single day cognisant of the honour that I have in serving as Australia’s 31st prime minister.
I’m also very aware of the responsibility that comes with it. I’m also very conscious of the power that comes with it. Power should never be [taken lightly].
Anthony Albanese delivers speech on censure motion
It wasn’t set in stone that the PM would speak on this. He is facing an almost empty chamber as he does – there are only a handful of Coalition MPs left in the chamber.
Bridget Archer: ‘This is not a game’
I’ve said time and time again that we talk very much in this House about the great privilege and honour of being here. But we talk less often about the responsibility that comes with that. There is a great privilege that comes with being the prime minister. But with that comes great responsibility and accountability. Which you can’t have without transparency.
And it might be a shock to some who sit here from all sides, but this is not a game.
There are things that sit above the cut and thrust of politics and the essential motion goes to our system of democracy.
It would be remiss of me not to mention that for me this issue also sits at the heart of the ability of our party to move forward.
This is a clear opportunity for a line to be drawn and to move in the right direction. We must heed the message sent to us at the May election. Learn those lessons. Reset and move forward constructively.
In closing, I just say this. I am a Liberal. I believe in Liberal values. And our statement of values says this: we believe in the rule of law. Under it there is freedom for the nation and for all men and women. Democracy depends upon self-discipline, obedience to the law, and the honest administration of the law. And it is for this reason, I’m obligated to support this motion.
Bridget Archer: ‘I do not accept explanations’ made by Scott Morrison
Bridget Archer again shows her courage in speaking up when her party won’t, and criticises Scott Morrison’s speech and explanation.
I do not accept any of the explanations put forward by the former prime minister for his actions. And I’m deeply disappointed by the lack of genuine apology or, more importantly, understanding of the impact of these decisions.
Liberal Bridget Archer rises in support of the censure motion
The Liberal MP for Bass says it is not an attack on the three years of Scott Morrison’s leadership, but “rather a reflection on the specific actions taken, that in my view, defy the expectations we have for our leaders”.
As Virginia Bell concluded in her report, the actions taken were corrosive to trust in politics. Those actions sit outside the expectations of the Australian people. And it sits outside of how we expect elected representatives in the highest office to act.
I’ve relentlessly advocated for more integrity in politics and fought for an integrity commission that would begin to restore the public’s faith. In elected officials. To sit quietly now would be hypocritical and I firmly believe we should be intentional in the actions we take to ensure that we do not let this happen again.
Paul Karp says Anthony Albanese is speaking to the teals (Kate Chaney, Zoe Daniel, Allegra Spender, Sophie Scamps, Monique Ryan) in the chamber.
Julian Leeser then moves on to how he is surprised the government hasn’t added a ‘burning of an effigy of the former prime minister’ ahead of each sitting, along with the morning prayers.
This is what the shadow attorney general has against the censure motion.
Julian Leeser says Albanese government not elected ‘to look in the rearview mirror’
Shadow attorney general also says it does nothing to help the Australian people to put food on the table, or lower the cost of living.
So I guess there is no point for a national anti-corruption commission, given it doesn’t put food on the table or lower the cost of living.
The opposition’s matters of public importance debates about how terrible the government is are also a waste of time.
We should also not work on improving standards of behaviour, working to end violence or any other policy for social good. Because it doesn’t put food on the table or lower the cost of living.
I mean, honestly.
Morrison congratulated after censure speech
Mike Bowers is still in the chamber – here are some of the MPs who lined up to shake Scott Morrison’s hand after he finished his speech arguing against his censure (most then left the chamber).
Just a reminder this wasn’t a valedictory (although it could be argued it was an audition for the speakers’ circuit) – it was in defence of his actions to take a suite of extra ministries in secret. He didn’t even tell them, his colleagues – the people he led (ultimately to a historic defeat). And yet here they are, lining up to shake his hand.

Bob Katter ends his speech but no one in the chamber appears any clearer on what he thinks about it all.
NSW Nationals leader refuses to back federal colleagues on voice vote

Michael McGowan
The New South Wales Nationals leader, Paul Toole, has refused to back his federal colleagues in their opposition to the voice to parliament, saying his party room had yet to form a position on the referendum and stressing the need to consult on the vote.
Flanked by the bulk of his party room, the federal Nationals leader, David Littleproud, on Tuesday announced the party would oppose the referendum.
But the decision was not unanimous: Andrew Gee became the first to break ranks, saying he would support the vote, as did the WA Nationals leader, Mia Davies.
Toole, the state’s deputy premier, said NSW had not yet formed a position on the vote and left open the possibility of letting individual MPs campaign for either side of the referendum.
This is a conversation that our party room will have at some point in the future. But again, this is a matter for the federal government.
Asked whether his Nationals colleagues had been too hasty in opposing the referendum, Toole said it was “a matter for the federal Nationals party”, but he said he was keen to consult widely on the referendum, particularly with Aboriginal communities.
I think there needs to be good consultation with our Aboriginal communities right across the state, or that is something that I’m very keen to continue to hear from those groups.
I think it’s important that the consultation is done widely, it’s respectful, and we understand the views that are given from all sides.
We will have that conversation. We know that if there is a referendum, we’ll have to get all the information provided [and] then we’ll have a stance. It might even be a stance where individual members have various views, and they’ll be able to share that with their communities to inform how they would like their community to vote on such a referendum.
On Wednesday Toole also conceded the withdrawal of about 33,000 Covid-19 fines had been due to an “error” with the drafting of the Public Health Orders, but denied police had been “overzealous” in enforcing the pandemic-era laws.
Police were not overzealous, police were undertaking the public health orders. They were following the public health orders to keep the community safe. I’ll back our police in each and every day for the work that they did to keep the community safe.
Bob Katter, in his speech (hard to say if he is for or against the censure), once again says he did not swear allegiance to “a lady in England” like the rest of the chamber did.
We have already checked this out – he did swear allegiance to the Queen. Signed and delivered.

Luke Henriques-Gomes
Robodebt royal commission to call Scott Morrison and Marise Payne in December
Scott Morrison and Marise Payne will front a royal commission into the botched robodebt scheme next month.
The former prime minister was social services minister when the failed Centrelink debt recovery scheme was established in 2015, while Payne was human services minister.
A witness list published by the royal commission on Wednesday confirms Morrison will give evidence on Wednesday 14 December. Payne is scheduled to appear on Tuesday 13 December.
A key line of inquiry for the commission is how legal advice – that warned the scheme could be unlawful – was treated by the public service and ministers. The program was implemented in 2015 without legislation, and subsequently found to be unlawful in 2019, culminating in a $1.8bn settlement with hundreds of thousands of victims.
The commission has previously heard Morrison had asked the Department of Human Services to develop Centrelink compliance proposals that could be considered for the 2015 budget. Among those proposals was what became the robodebt scheme.
Kathryn Campbell, the secretary of the Department of Human Services at the time the scheme was being devised, told the commission briefing documents she prepared for Morrison had said it was likely such a plan could not be implemented without legislation.
The commission is yet to hear how or why that advice was disregarded to allow what became the robodebt scheme to be included in the May 2015 budget.
The inquiry has heard Payne was also briefed on early versions of the plan.
The commission’s second block of hearings will last two weeks and commence next month.
Campbell will continue her evidence on Wednesday 7 December, while other senior and mid-level managers from the departments of social services and human services will also give evidence.
The Liberal MP for Menzies, Keith Wolahan, said he believed it was important to stay for the first few speeches in this censure motion, Paul Karp reports, but he won’t be voting for it.
So far, it is just Bridget Archer who is crossing the floor.
Lots of little side chats in the chamber.



















Discussion about this post