A manuscript attributed to Galileo Galilei that was ruled a forgery in August 2022 has led to the discovery of another book that the famous Italian astronomer actually wrote but under a pseudonym, a new investigation suggests. This is reported by Live Science. Previously unpublished notes of Galileo, which were examined after the discovery of the forgery, showed that he was the real author of a treatise entitled Considerazioni Astronomiche di Alimberto Mauri (“Astronomical Considerations by Alimberto Mauri”), published in 1604. Some scholars had already suspected , that Galileo was the author of the work, although it was attributed to the pseudonym Alemberto Mauri. At the time, writing under a pseudonym was common practice to avoid controversy.
Galileo is known to have published under other pseudonyms, but his authorship of the Considerazioni Astronomiche has not been confirmed until now. “It’s a complete treatise and it was written by one of the most brilliant minds in Western science,” says discoverer Matteo Cosci, a researcher at the Department of Philosophy and Cultural Heritage at Ca Foscari University in Venice. The treatise was published only a few years before Galileo’s famous work Sidereus Nuncius (“Starry Messenger”), which in 1610 described his revolutionary observations of the Moon and four of Jupiter’s moons through the first recorded astronomical telescope. “You can think of it as a prequel to Sidereus Nuncius, which changed the history of astronomy and science in general,” says Kosci. “For historians, this is a real treasure trove.”
Why did Galileo write under a pseudonym?
The discovery that Galileo was the author of the Considerazioni Astronomiche was linked to the earlier discovery that a manuscript in the University of Michigan library attributed to the great astronomer was actually a forgery. As the scientists found, the watermarks on the paper indicated that it must have been written more than 100 years after Galileo’s death, making the document a forgery. It was likely created by the resourceful Italian forger Tobia Nicotra sometime in the 1920s or 1930s, a university investigation found. The manuscript was acquired at auction in 1934 and donated to the university in 1938. The investigation also found that two letters used to authenticate the manuscript were also forgeries, again possibly by Nicotra; and since one of the letters also claimed that Galileo had written the Considerazioni Astronomiche, this too was suspect.
Galileo Galilei never admitted to writing the Considerazioni Astronomiche di Alimberto Mauri, and so far the only evidence has been the forged letter. But earlier this year Cosci discovered in a Florence library an unpublished note, authentically written by Galileo, in which the astronomer listed several places where the Italian scientist Ludovico delle Colombe had attacked his ideas. Among them, Galileo noted that Delle Colombe had criticized the Considerazioni Astronomiche di Alimberto Mauri. This shows that Galileo felt personally attacked whenever Alemberto Mauri was criticized, Cosci says. “When Galileo wrote in his personal note that ‘[Lodovico delle Colombe] speaks of me with contempt,’ he identified himself as a Moor,” the researcher notes.
Galileo’s controversial theories
According to Cosci, Delle Colombe published a treatise claiming that a “nova star” seen in 1604 (actually a supernova) was not new at all, but rather permanent and seen only from time to time. These ideas coincided with the prevailing Aristotelian theories, embodied in Ptolemy’s geocentric model of the solar system, which held that the Sun, planets, and stars were fixed and unchanging and that they revolved around the Earth. But Galileo, writing under the pseudonym Alemberto Mauri, suggested that the “new star” was actually a supernova and proposed mechanisms that could have created it – a challenge to Aristotle’s view. He also introduced several other radical ideas for his time, such as that there could be mountains on the moon. “It’s safer to use a pseudonym because if things don’t go right, then they don’t blame you,” says Peter Barker, a professor of history of science at the University of Oklahoma. “But if they succeed, you can say, ‘It was me all along.’
The attribution of the Considerazioni Astronomiche to Galileo is also accepted by Nick Wilding, a Georgia State University historian who discovered the forgery of the manuscript at the University of Michigan. “This is an excellent example of how patient and intelligent archival research can undo some of the damage done by forgers,” says Wilding. – Dr. Cosci demonstrates to us that a combination of skepticism and skill will lead us to the historical truth.” According to Cosci himself, Galileo wrote the Considerazioni Astronomiche when he was teaching at the University of Padua. The treatise may have been Galileo’s attempt to find patronage in Rome, as it was dedicated to the Pope’s treasurer, the researcher suggests. But Rome and Venice were embroiled in a diplomatic dispute at the time, “so it would have been unwise of Galileo to put his name to a treatise dedicated to the public enemy,” notes Cosci.
Photo: The title page of a treatise written under the pseudonym Alimberto Mauri, published in 1604, now revealed to be by Galileo Galilei. (Apresso Gio, Antonio Caneo, 1606 / CCA 4.0)



















Discussion about this post