Sunak suggests MPs will vote on his proposed NI protocol deal
Starmer tells Tory MPs they are cheering Sunak pulling the wool over their eyes. Will Sunak confirm that MPs will get a vote on the final deal.
Sunak says of course the Commons will express its view.
This suggests that there will be a vote of some kind.
Key events
No 10 says prospect of Commons vote on NI protocol deal is ‘hypothetical’ because no agreement reached yet
Pippa Crerar
Rishi Sunak’s press secretary has clarified that the prospect of a Commons vote is “hypothetical” as no deal on the Northern Ireland protocol has yet been struck.
“We’re not going to get ahead of ourselves, talks are ongoing, we don’t yet have a deal,” she told reporters. “There is nothing to vote on yet, we don’t have a deal”.
Downing Street also revealed that Sunak spoke again with European Commission president Ursula Von Der Leyen last night. They discussed “good progress” that had been made on negotiations and would talk again “in coming days”.
However, there are no scheduled discussions planned for Thursday at this stage, and VDL is supposed to be in Italy, suggesting it less likely she will travel to London.
PMQs – snap verdict
That was very 2019: Keir Starmer asking about Brexit (he was shadow Brexit secretary back then); Labour offering to support a Tory PM against their own backbenchers (although this time Starmer meant it – he wants the Northern Ireland protocol row with the EU settled before the general election); and the Tories accusing Labour of “surrender”.
This script eventually played out in Boris Johnson’s favour just over three years ago. But today Rishi Sunak was clearly on the back foot, and Starmer artfully illustrated how precarious his position is.
At press conferences the trick for journalists is to identify the question that they know the politician can’t or won’t answer. That is what Starmer was doing today? Would Sunak confirm that the protocol deal was going to involve Northern Ireland continuing “to follow some EU law”? Would Sunak confirm that there will be a continuing role for the European court of justice? Would Sunak confirm that, if there is a deal, the Northern Ireland protocol bill would be abandoned? And would Sunak commit to giving MPs a vote?
Sunak half-answered the final question – implying that there would be a vote, without saying so explicitly – but the other three questions, he would not touch at all.
And Starmer had a good line ready in response to Sunak’s reticence.
The sound you here is them [Tory MPs] cheering the prime minister pulling the wool over their eyes.
In a speech in Belfast last month Starmer portrayed Sunak as being in hock to “a Brexit purity cult [in the Conservative party], which can never be satisfied”. Today’s exchanges amounted to a show and tell follow-up.
Sunak did not want to engage with Starmer’s questions. But there were a few clues as to his latest thinking on the protocol from what he said and, even though he is clearly nervous about upsetting the ERG hardliners, a massive revolt when the deal does get published does not look inevitable and could still be avoided. I will post more on the minutiae of his Brexit answers shortly.
On the politics, Sunak resorted to accuses Sunak, and Labour, of being opposed to Brexit and pandering to Brussels. He said:
It’s his usual position when it comes to the European Union, it’s give the EU a blank cheque and agree to anything they offer. It’s not a strategy, that’s surrender.
He also accused Stamer of serial inconsistency in his final response. Referring to Starmer’s plan to announce five election missions for Labour in a speech tomorrow, Sunak said:
We already know what they are: it’s uncontrolled immigration; it’s reckless spending; it’s higher debts; and it’s softer sentences; and for the fifth pledge we all know that he reserves the right to change his mind on the other four.
Given that Starmer has changed his position on some issues considerably since he ran for Labour leader, this final charge carries some clout. But the “surrender” accusation on Brexit just sounded stale. Most Brexiters realise that leaving the EU has not worked out quite as planned, and so just re-running the 2019 insults doesn’t sound plausible.
Charlotte Nichols (Lab) asks what support the government can offer people in Warrington in the light of the murder of Brianna Ghey.
Sunak says the Home Office wants to ensure that schools, and the community, get the support they need.
Sir Bill Wiggin (Con) asks the PM to publish the small boats bill next week.
Sunak says he and the home secretary are working as quickly as they can to bring in that legislation.
Sir Robert Buckland, the former justice secretary, congratulates the PM for negotiating a deal with the EU. Does the PM agree treaty change is the best way to change the protocol, not legislation in this parliament (ie, the Northern Ireland protocol bill).
Sunak says new arrangements must be in place.
He ignores Buckland’s invitation to get him to say the protocol bill will be permanently shelved.
Helen Morgan (Lib Dem) asks when the government will ensure the NHS has the GPs it needs.
Sunak says there are 2,200 more GPs in practice today, and 30,000 more nurses. That is because record funding has gone in.
David Mundell (Con) says TransPennine offers “appalling” service. And he says their decision to cancel services so the cancellations do not show up in the figures is unacceptable.
Sunak agrees this is unacceptable. The contract expires in May. If ministers conclude the service cannot be turned around, other decisons will be made.
John McNally (SNP) asks Sunak if he will follow the example of the Scottish government, and introduce a child payment.
Sunak says the best poverty strategy is to have everyone in work.
Theo Clarke (Con) asks if the govenrment will reconsider a decision to locate 500 asylum seekers in Stafford.
Sunak says this is why the government must stem the tide and stop the boats. He says Clarke can have a meeting with the Home Office.
Ed Davey, the Lib Dem leader, says MPs are united in their support for Ukraine.
He says the Tory manifesto promised 40 new hospitals. But most of those have not got planning permission yet. He says some staff and patients are dealing with unacceptable conditions.
Sunak says he is proud the government is investing record sums in the NHS. The most recent figures show considerable improvement in waiting times for emergency care, he says.
Tan Dhesi (Lab) asks about money wasted during Covid on contracts for equipement that was not suitable. When will that money be recovered so MPs can get a decent pay rise?
Sunak says he is glad talks with the RCN are happening. If Dhesi cares about his constituents, he should stand up to Labour’s union paymasters and back the strikes bill.
Sunak says addressing democratic deficit is ‘essential part’ of ongoing talks on NI protocol
Sir Jeffrey Donaldson, the DUP leader, thanks the PM for his efforts in relation to the protocol. But it must be replaced, he says. Does the PM accept how important the constitutional and democratic issues are? Does he agree it is unacceptable for EU laws to be imposed on Northern Ireland without its consent? And does he agree the legal text of the protocol must be rewritten.
Sunak says he knows the concerns raised by Donaldson are genuine. He says addressing the democratic defict is an “essential part” of the negotiations with the EU that are ongoing.
Jereme Mayhew (Con) asks about a hospital in his Broadland constituency.
Sunak says the hospital has already had money to address its immediate problems.
Stephen Flynn, the SNP leader at Westminster, says wholesale gas prices have fallen by 75% from their peak. So why are gas bills going up?
Sunak says the government is spending tens of billions providing MPs with help with their energy bills. He quotes an SNP figure saying, if the SNP were a pizza company, their products would be “slow, wrong and costly”.
Flynn says the fall in wholesale energy prices has given the government a windfall of £15bn. He says bills should be reduced, not increased.
Sunak says households are saving £900 from the energy price guarantee.
Starmer says Labour will support the government in any vote.
Sunak says Starmer is due to announce five missions tomorrow. The fifth one will be Starmer confirming he has the right to change his mind, he says.
Sunak suggests MPs will vote on his proposed NI protocol deal
Starmer tells Tory MPs they are cheering Sunak pulling the wool over their eyes. Will Sunak confirm that MPs will get a vote on the final deal.
Sunak says of course the Commons will express its view.
This suggests that there will be a vote of some kind.
Starmer asks Sunak to confirm that, if he gets a deal with the EU, he will pull the Northern Ireland protocol bill.
Sunak refuses to answer, and attacks Starmer’s record on Brexit.
Sunak accuses Starmer of backing ‘surrender’ to EU
Starmer accuses Sunak of not being open about what is planned.
Sunak says the deal is still not finalised. He says Starmer is following his usual strategy of giving the EU what it wants. That is “surrender”, he says.
Sunak refuses to say Northern Ireland would still have to follow some EU law under his proposed deal
Starmer says Boris Johnson told businesses there would be no checks or barriers of any kind. That was “nonsense” and damaged trust. Will the deal Sunak is seeking involve Northern Ireland having to follow some EU law?
Sunak says Starmer is jumping ahead. They are still in discussion, he says. His deal must respect sovereignty for Northern Ireland.



















Discussion about this post