The Health and Disability Commissioner has found Te Whatu
Ora Nelson Marlborough, and a general surgeon, breached the
Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights
(the Code) in their care of a man in his sixties.
The
man underwent an acute colonoscopy to investigate
gastrointestinal bleeding. During the procedure he suffered
a peri-respiratory arrest and had to be intubated. It was
later discovered he had suffered a perforation to his colon,
and he subsequently passed away.
Morag McDowell found
Te Whatu Ora Nelson Marlborough (formerly Nelson Marlborough
DHB) breached Right 4(5) of the Code which states consumers
have the right to co-operation among providers, to ensure
quality and continuity of services.
Her decision also
found the surgeon breached Right 4(1) of the Code which
gives consumers the right to have services provided with
reasonable care and skill.
The patient had several
co-morbidities including a prior pneumonectomy (lung
removal) to treat lung cancer. This history was relevant in
guiding clinical decision making. However, the surgeon was
not fully aware of the patient’s medical history at the
time the colonoscopy was performed.
Ms McDowell
concluded that Te Whatu Ora Nelson Marlborough did not
communicate effectively to ensure the coordination of the
man’s care. In particular, there was no nurse-to-nurse
handover from the ward to the endoscopy suite and the
endoscopy team was unaware of the man’s prior
pneumonectomy until serious difficulties were
encountered.
Oversights around communication and
handover of care meant the endoscopy team were not able to
consider the implications that the pneumonectomy might have
on the sedation dose chosen and removed the opportunity for
a different approach to the patient’s sedation and
procedure.
Ms McDowell says, “Where multiple
clinicians and teams are involved in a patient’s
treatment, particularly a patient with significant
co-morbidities, robust and open communication is the
cornerstone of providing safe and effective
care.”
“While individual staff members hold some
degree of responsibility for their failings, I consider that
the deficiencies outlined indicate a service level
communication breakdown at Te Whatu Ora Nelson Marlborough,
for which it bears responsibility at an organisational
level,” Ms McDowell said.
Ms McDowell found the
surgeon in breach of the Code for failing to review the
man’s clinical notes prior to the procedure.
“As
this Office has stated previously, the onus is on the
clinician to ask the relevant questions, examine the patient
and keep proper records,” said Ms McDowell.
Ms
McDowell made a number of recommendations including for Te
Whatu Ora Nelson Marlborough and the surgeon to provide
written apologies to the patient’s whānau.
However,
she also acknowledged that significant and useful internal
recommendations have already been undertaken by Te Whatu Ora
and the surgeon as a result of their own review of these
events. These changes include:
– Amending the booking
process so that acute endoscopies are ordinarily performed
by the general surgery service in the operating
theatre.
– Providing an appropriate pathway for
anaesthetist-led sedation for patients with multiple
co-morbidities who have an urgent need for a
colonoscopy.
– Reviewing the safety check list used
prior to procedures and including a section to highlight
relevant co-morbidities and patients’ capacity to give
informed consent.
– Implementing an “Introduction,
Situation, Background, Assessment and Recommendation”
(ISBAR) guided handover policy (for ward nurse to endoscopy
nurse handover).
– Updating the “Transfer of Patients
to and from Operating Theatre” policy to clarify that
patients transferring from the ward to the endoscopy unit
require a nurse escort.
– Reviewing and updating the
“Serious Adverse Event Review” policy with a flow chart
detailing staff responsibilities.
Notes
The
full report of this case can be viewed on HDC’s website –
see HDC’s ‘ Latest
Decisions‘.
Names have been removed from the
report to protect privacy of the individual involved in this
case. We anticipate that the Commissioner will name DHBs and
public hospitals found in breach of the Code unless it would
not be in the public interest or would unfairly compromise
the privacy interests of an individual provider or a
consumer. HDC’s naming policy can be found on our website
here.
HDC
promotes and protects the rights of people using health and
disability services as set out in the Code
of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights (the
Code).
In 2021/22 HDC made 402 recommendations for
quality improvement and providers complied with 98% of those
recommendations.
Learn more: Education
Publications
© Scoop Media



















Discussion about this post