Mafia Mamma (R16, 101 mins) Directed by Catherine Hardwicke *½
I’m beginning to think Australians shouldn’t go to Italy. Or, at least, Australian actors shouldn’t go to Italy to make films.
Just last week, I drove my tired arse out to Lower Hutt and sat through The Pope’s Exorcist – a horror movie, we were told, that made me laugh more than any actual comedy has in months. And yes, I know that technically Pope’s Exorcist star Russell Crowe is one of ours. But Duran Duran were still in the charts when he hopped the ditch – and frankly, good luck to him – and finder’s keepers.
On Wednesday night, I schlepped up the hills to the mighty Penthouse cinema, in Wellington’s Brooklyn, to watch actual, undeniable Aussie Toni Collette in Mafia Mamma – an alleged comedy about a woman who becomes head of an Italian crime family, only to find it had practically no laughs and a couple of scenes of such gruesome violence, including an attempted rape, it easily earned that R16 rating you see above.
READ MORE:
* Shackleton: The Greatest Story of Survival: Innovative doco offers fresh insights, perspective
* The Pope’s Exorcist: Russell Crowe’s tacky, tediously competent revisionist nonsense
* Air: Ben Affleck’s tale of Nike’s courting of Michael Jordan flies thanks to smart writing, great casting
* Dungeons & Dragons: Honour Among Thieves: An action-comedy that’s a huge pile of fun
Mafia Mamma is a lousy film. Let’s just get that out of the way immediately. Analyze This, this ain’t.
Collette stars as 40-something Kristin, living in suburban USA. She has a husband who is cartoonishly unappealing and a teenage son who seems pretty great. We meet Kristin as she is tearfully sending the boy off to college, far away in Portland. A few moments of screen-time later, Kristin is taking a phone call, when she walks in on the husband having sex with the boy’s career counsellor.
BLEECKER STREET
Toni Collette is a Mafia Mamma.
The phone call, fortuitously, I guess, was from a woman in Italy, telling Kristin that her grandfather, who she has never met, has died. And that Kristin has inherited a vineyard. With no reason not to – and her head filled with visions of an Eat, Pray, Bonk excursion to get her out from under the damp wreck of her marriage, Kristin hops on a plane that night and makes her way to Southern Italy and the Calabria. Which, by Mafia Mamma’s grasp of geography, is about a 30-minute drive from central Rome.
What ensues kind of does what the trailer promises, but worse than you could imagine.
Supplied
Toni Collette stars opposite Giulio Corso in Mafia Mamma.
Grandpa, of course, was really a mafia Don. For no reason that makes any sense at all, he has left control of his family to Kristin. We realise soon enough that the film should have belonged to Monica Bellucci, somehow retaining a few shreds of dignity as Bianca, the old man’s mistress and fixer. In fact, if you removed Kristin from the script completely and rewrote Mafia Mamma as a vehicle for Bianca/Bellucci, it might even have worked.
Collette tries hard, mugging, preening, scowling and sobbing like she’s getting paid by the facial expression and the mortgage is overdue. Around Collette and Bellucci, the remaining characters are such obvious, outdated caricatures of Italian-ness, the script registers more as a hate-crime than as an actual film.
Supplied
If Mafia Mamma had been rewritten as a vehicle for Monica Bellucci’s Bianca, it might even have worked.
Mafia Mamma is hopelessly contrived and lazy. The few laugh-worthy moments it has are drowned in poor timing, sloppy staging and inexplicable levels of violence and gore. If this was supposed to be someone’s idea of “edgy”, they missed by a mile.
Director Catherine Hardwicke (Thirteen) has far more high points than low on her CV, but this howler is going to take a lot to get over.
Mafia Mamma is now screening in select cinemas nationwide.



















Discussion about this post