• Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe Now
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
The Insight Post
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Science

Associate Editors: Please Jump in the Mosh Pit

by Theinsightpost
June 26, 2024
in Science
0 0
0
Associate Editors: Please Jump in the Mosh Pit

Disclosing conflicts of interest (COI), financial or otherwise, is quite rightly a compulsory part of scientific discourse. After all, motivated reasoning and bias is often subconscious, and even honest and well-meaning scientists can be inadvertently swayed. Ironically, however, a far more insidious intrinsic COI (iCOI) is both ubiquitous and unstated in academia. Academics who fail to publish papers and secure grants can lose their labs, might be relegated to undesirable professional tasks, could experience lowering of salaries, and may ultimately be discharged. This scenario poses an omnipresent conflict for essentially all authors who have no conflicts to declare.  As Upton Sinclair famously quipped, “It is difficult to get [people] to understand something when [their] salary depends upon not understanding it.”1

In their landmark paper modeling the effects of what is commonly called p-hacking, researchers from the University of Pennsylvania and the University of California, Berkeley showed that the subtle introduction of degrees of freedom rendered a p-value cutoff of 0.05 essentially meaningless, as it resulted in a 61 percent chance of a type I error.2 P-hacking, data dredging, and data mining have become pejorative terms for the common practice of looking at data from multiple angles, which is a requisite part of good science. The problem is that researchers may think they have only tested one hypothesis when they have inadvertently tested multiple hypotheses. Use of a statistical test that doesn’t account for multiple hypothesis testing then overestimates significance. This is part of what has been coined the reproducibility crisis, and the researchers presented a list of potential remedies in the paper. They made six recommendations to authors and four to reviewers. All the recommendations focused on increased rigor, with one exception that stated, “Reviewers should be more tolerant of imperfections in results.” It might seem strange that a paper focused on increasing rigor advocated greater tolerance for imperfections. The reason is that if standards of scientific publication are too high, then the pressures of iCOI drive distortion, exaggeration, and at times outright lying. It remains a publish or perish world and no one wants to perish.

Continue reading below…

Peer review is one of the sacred characteristics of modern science that makes scientific claims distinct. The validity of a claim is not based upon the authors’ authority; rather, qualified peers determine the validity of researchers’ claims based upon the data. Usually, the reviewers are anonymous, so they feel free to give an unvarnished assessment without the fear of political fallout. This process helps remedy the confirmation bias that humans seem quite incapable of escaping from, despite actively trying. This is not to say that reviewers are not prone to their own particular biases as well, but they may view the data from a different perspective than the authors. As such, what is confirmation bias for a reviewer may serve as disconfirmation bias against the authors’ claims. In this way, the thought collective has a more balanced internal dialogue.

In the legal system, District Attorneys ultimately decide who is (and who is not) prosecuted and what penalties are sought. It is for this reason that Supreme Court Justice Robert Jackson stated, “The district attorney has more control over life, liberty, and reputation than any other person in America.”3 Similarly, in a scientific peer review system, journal associate editors decide which papers get reviewed, who reviews them, and how to adjudicate the dialogue between authors and reviewers during paper modification. Thus, editors exert tremendous control over the publication process. However, some associate editors may be failing the field by mistaking detached nonparticipation for unbiased impartiality.      

Peer review is essential to ensure that author claims are held to the standard of being supported by observation, interpretation, and reason. However, the peer reviewer should be no less bound by these same standards. Sometimes, however, a reviewer may dislike the findings in a paper for myriad reasons other than those based on observation and interpretation. Worse, reviewers could be biased for political or personal reasons unrelated to the science. Any paper can be killed by pulling out the old armamentarium of thought-ending clichés that facilitate “manuscriptocide.” In such cases, an author may be rendered helpless. 

Continue reading below…

Ideally, the authors can appeal to the associate editor to determine the validity of the reviewers’ comments. However, at least in my experience and opinion, associate editors have become far too hesitant to get involved. Rather, associate editors more often serve as a procedural jurist, facilitating dialogue between authors and reviewers, with reviewer placation remaining the metric of acceptability. This amounts to requiring unanimous approval for publication and allows a single reviewer to hang the jury, resulting in paper rejection. If the bar is too high for publication, and if we allow the perfect to be the enemy of the good, then iCOI and the need to maintain academic productivity becomes an enormous force of motivated reasoning that will drive p-hacking and other missteps, intentionally or otherwise.4

In some cases, the associate editor may recruit an additional peer reviewer to assess the paper, but this is a further evaluation of the authors’ claims, not an assessment of the disapproving reviewer’s reasoning. Rather, associate editors can and should review the reviewers. After all, editors are carefully chosen experts in their respective fields and are well qualified to evaluate both a paper and the reviewers’ comments. If a majority of reviewers are in favor of publication, overruling a single reviewer whose view is different is not a capricious action by an associate editor.

While overriding a reviewer’s comments risks replacing one bias with another and could encourage inappropriate favoritism, intrinsic bias, and cronyism, there might be other solutions. The editor could also facilitate debate amongst the reviewers, using reviewers to peer review the reasoning of the other reviewers. In this way, rather than being a passive administrator who recruits reviewers and is simply a referee as authors and reviewers hash it out, the associate editor becomes an active scientific mind in the process, which, at least in my view, is what the role entails.  

It is not helpful to have associate editors who are disengaged due to a distaste for conflict or lack of time to enter the fray when needed or are under the misguided notion that their role is procedural and not scientific. Of course, associate editors are themselves susceptible to iCOI and must therefore be senior and established enough to protect against actions based on fear of retribution from vindictive reviewers who may take umbrage at being overridden or vindictive authors who may lash out for being rejected. Associate editors who jump off the bench and wrestle in the mud, when required, are desperately needed. 

Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest: JZ is a cofounder of Svalinn Therapeutics. JZ also has the iCOI present for all academic scientists.

Continue reading below…

References

  1. Sinclair U. I, Candidate for Governor: And How I Got Licked. University of California Press; 1934.
  2. Simmons JP, et al. False-positive psychology: undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant. Psychol Sci. 2011;22(11):1359-1366.
  3. Jackson RH. The Federal Prosecuter. An Address Delivered at The Second Annual Conference of United States Attorneys: United States Department of Justice; 1940.
  4. Zimring JC, Spitalnik SL. Fallacy of perfection harms peer review. Nature. 2016;537(7618):34.
ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Discover the Best of Bangkok: Unforgettable adventures in the vibrant capital

Next Post

US Woman, 18, Arrested For Calling 911 To Avoid Going On Date With Man She Met Online

Related News

Groundbreaking Electric Comb Promises Hair Regrowth in Mice Within Four Weeks, Paving the Way for Future Hair-Loss Solutions
Science

Groundbreaking Electric Comb Promises Hair Regrowth in Mice Within Four Weeks, Paving the Way for Future Hair-Loss Solutions

November 18, 2026
Miniature LSD Doses Administered in Rapid Succession Show Antidepressant Potential in Mice: Exploring the Impact of Timing vs. Tolerance
Science

Miniature LSD Doses Administered in Rapid Succession Show Antidepressant Potential in Mice: Exploring the Impact of Timing vs. Tolerance

November 14, 2026
Investigation Underway: Experts Seek Answers Behind Sudden Brooklyn Building Collapse
Science

Investigation Underway: Experts Seek Answers Behind Sudden Brooklyn Building Collapse

November 12, 2026
Preserve the Unseen: The Essential Role of Parasites in Ecosystems
Science

Preserve the Unseen: The Essential Role of Parasites in Ecosystems

November 11, 2026
Next Post
US Woman, 18, Arrested For Calling 911 To Avoid Going On Date With Man She Met Online

US Woman, 18, Arrested For Calling 911 To Avoid Going On Date With Man She Met Online

Discussion about this post

Subscribe To Our Newsletters

    Customer Support


    1251 Wilcrest Drive
    Houston, Texas
    77042 USA
    Call-832.795.1420
    e-mail – news@theinsightpost.com

    Subscribe To Our Newsletters

      Categories

      • Africa
      • Africa-East
      • African Sports
      • American Sports
      • Arts
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • Business
      • Business Asia
      • Business- Africa
      • Canada
      • Defense
      • Education
      • Egypt
      • Energy
      • Entertainment
      • Europe
      • European Soccer
      • Finance
      • Germany
      • Ghana
      • Health
      • Insight
      • International
      • Investing
      • Japan
      • Latest Headlines
      • Life & Living
      • Markets
      • Mobile
      • Movies
      • New Zealand
      • Nigeria
      • Politics
      • Scholarships
      • Science
      • South Africa
      • South America
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • Travel-Africa
      • UK
      • USA
      • Weather
      • World
      No Result
      View All Result

      Recent News

      US Democrats Make History by Nominating Jeffries as First Black Speaker of the House

      US Democrats Make History by Nominating Jeffries as First Black Speaker of the House

      November 18, 2026
      Stephen A. Smith Stands Firm in Defense of Trump Interview Amidst Fact-Check Criticism

      Stephen A. Smith Stands Firm in Defense of Trump Interview Amidst Fact-Check Criticism

      November 18, 2026
      Vintage Photo of Robert Pattinson and Daniel Craig Gains New Significance Amid Bond Casting Developments

      Vintage Photo of Robert Pattinson and Daniel Craig Gains New Significance Amid Bond Casting Developments

      November 18, 2026
      Top 7 Retirement Threats and Effective Strategies to Navigate Them

      Top 7 Retirement Threats and Effective Strategies to Navigate Them

      November 18, 2026
      • Home
      • Advertise With Us
      • About Us
      • Corporate
      • Consumer Rewards
      • Forum
      • Privacy Policy
      • Social Trends

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In

      Add New Playlist

      We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

      You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in .

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Insight
      • Blog
      • Business
      • Entertainment
      • Health
      • Politics
      • Shop
        • Gift Shop
        • Value Shop
        • Store
        • Bargain Shop
        • Discount
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • USA
      • Video
      • World
        • Asia
        • Africa
        • South America
        • North America
        • Europe
        • Oceania

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      The Insight Post
      Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

      Strictly Necessary Cookies

      Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

      Cookie Policy

      More information about our Cookie Policy