Whangārei’s fluoridation rebellion is intensifying with
the Director-General of Health threatening to potentially
pull rank and turn on the switch to add fluoride to the
city’s drinking water if the council continues its
defiance.
This comes as ratepayers face the prospect
of almost $5 million in potential extra Whangārei District
Council (WDC) costs after councillors voted in December
against adding fluoridation to the water.
In a
strongly-worded letter to WDC Mayor Vince Cocurullo and
chief executive Simon Weston, Director-General of Health Dr
Diana Sarfati told the council it was an offence under the
Health Act 1956 for a local authority to contravene a
direction (to fluoridate).
She said the minister of
health could seek a rare High Court writ of mandamus – a
type of court order – overriding WDC’s refusal and forcing
it to flick the switch for fluoridating its drinking
water.
If enacted, it will likely be a New Zealand
first.
The writ enables the Director-General to turn
on the fluoridation switch herself or order council staff or
contractors to do so.
“The act also provides that in
circumstances where a local authority is in default of its
legal obligations, the Director-General of Health may
perform those obligations,” she said.
WDC is the only
council among 14 refusing to fluoridate its drinking water
after the government’s August 2022 directive. It must
fluoridate by 28 March.

Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
Sarfati
said WDC’s role was to implement the Director-General’s
directions. It was under a mandatory statutory duty to
comply with these.
“As such, the council has no
discretion to refuse to comply with a
direction.”
Weston said the Director-General could
compel the council to perform any duty it had failed to
carry out under the Act.
Refusing to comply also
brought the risk of Minister for Local Government Simon
Watts intervening, Weston said.
Sarfati wrote to WDC
on 30 January in response to its 18 December decision to
seek a High Court injunction and fluoridation deadline
extension.
This followed the council’s 28 November
decision not to fluoridate.
“I reiterate that I expect
the council to comply with its direction by the required
date, which is 28 March, 2025, and I do not consider there
is a basis for an extension,” Sarfati said.
She said
the minister of health could apply to the High Court for a
writ of mandamus to compel WDC to perform any duty it had
failed to perform under the act.
A short-notice
extraordinary WDC meeting on Wednesday will revisit the
council’s November 28 fluoridation decision in the wake of
Sarfati’s letter.
She has requested a letter from WDC
before 5pm on Valentines Day, confirming whether the council
intends to comply with the fluoridation direction for
Whangārei and Bream Bay by 28 March.
Cocurullo,
Deputy Mayor Phil Halse and councillors Benney, Jayne
Golightly, Marie Olsen, Simon Reid and Phoenix Ruka pushed
for the injunction at WDC’s 18 December
meeting.
Meanwhile councillors Nick Connop, Ken
Couper, Deb Harding, Patrick Holmes, Scott McKenzie, Carol
Peters and Paul Yovich were against.
Cocurullo, who
used his casting vote at the December meeting in favour of
seeking a deadline extension and injunction, would not
comment on Sarfati’s representations in the wake of her
letter.
Neither would he be drawn on whether the
council should continue with its fluoridation ban or change
tack at the meeting on Wednesday.
He said the council
was being responsible in its decision not to fluoridate, due
to health concerns, which it had to take into account under
legislation such as the Local Government
Act.
Cocurullo said ordering the council to fluoridate
meant removing the community’s right to have a say in the
important fluoridation decision.
Weston said
councillors risked personal liability for financial
penalties resulting from failing to carry out the
fluoridation direction. This risk also applied to
staff.

Sarfati’s
letter threatened heavy non-compliance penalties under the
Health Act.
“The Act provides for potentially heavy
penalties upon any conviction by a court. The ministry (of
Health) will consider whether prosecutions should be
commenced on a case-by-case basis in accordance with the
Solicitor-General’s prosecution guidelines,” Sarfati
said.
WDC ratepayers face the prospect of paying
significantly towards the $4.857 million in extra costs as a
result of the council’s current position.
That’s from
having to pay back or miss out on $4.557 million the
government’s putting towards necessary fluoridation
equipment for the district’s five water treatment plants
including at Whau Valley; a potential fine of up to $200,000
for not complying with the directive (with an added $10,000
a day for every day or part-day WDC doesn’t comply after the
28 March deadline), at least $100,000 should the council
seek an injunction (with other costs on top of that likely
including paying for the Ministry of Health court costs if
the application is lost).
Northland law firm director
Jeremy Brown has been appointed by the council working party
set up at the 18 December meeting to seek an
injunction.
Weston, the council chief executive, said
the court was likely to treat an application for an Interim
injunction with scepticism, given the council had already
received government funding for fluoridation
infrastructure.
Sarfati said there was no legal
uncertainty about the government’s August 2022 fluoridation
directions.
– LDR is local body journalism
co-funded by RNZ and NZ On
Air.
© Scoop Media




















Discussion about this post