For the first time in 12 years, Auckland’s mayoral race looks more like contests in Hamilton and Wellington than the traditional “whale versus minnows”, an experienced political strategist says.
Following the left-leaning template set with Len Brown’s 2010 win over John Banks in the inaugural Auckland Council election, the battles have been between an almost-certainty, and unlikely challengers.
“You had one whale and a few minnows,” is how Chamanthie Sinhalage-Fonseka puts it.
With (narrow) poll-leader Efeso Collins and businessman Wayne Brown looking more like a head-to-head contest, “neither is the whale” in Sinhalage-Fonseka’s view.
READ MORE:
* Auckland mayoralty: Wayne Brown’s ‘fixes’ put under the microscope
* It’s over to voters as the clock counts down to Auckland’s new council
* Auckland mayoralty: The hints Viv Beck left about withdrawing from the race
Auckland’s field has narrowed from where it was just six weeks ago, when due to vagaries of polling for local body elections, there was a cluster of four leading candidates: Collins, Brown, the now-departed Leo Molloy and Viv Beck.
“That was closer to a Wellington or Hamilton-style election, community people with profiles in their own circles,” she said.
Sinhalage-Fonseka is now a senior public relations consultant, and this is the first election she watches simply as a voter, having had campaign and mayoral staff roles in both Hamilton and Wellington.
The last published poll was just prior to Molloy’s August 12, withdrawal, saying he “can’t win”, meaning there’s no clear picture of the race without him, and without Beck who pulled the plug five weeks later but remains on the voting papers.
Ricky Wilson/Stuff
Wayne Brown (left) and Efeso Collins are the leading contenders in Auckland’s mayoral contest.
Where this leaves Collins and Brown relative to each other, and potentially the 2019 third-place getter Craig Lord, is unclear in a race with 22 candidates.
“You can shine in debates, the media write good lines, but with Auckland’s projected low turnout, your base can be lethargic, the risk is the candidate with more uncertainty could get people to vote for them,” she said.
Sinhalage-Fonseka said south Auckland-based Collins and central city dweller Brown had different strategies.
“Wayne (Brown) from the start has had targetted marketing – I’ve barely seen any on my personal channels, which means I’m not in his demographic.”
DAVID WHITE/STUFF
Chamanthie Sinhalage-Fonseka is for the first time in a decade, not part of a local body election campaign. (File photo)
Brown has made no secret he is chasing the “over-50 property owner” as they are the group most likely to vote. He’s talked of funding a $500,000 campaign and has regular slots in ad breaks on prime-time television, and on talkback radio.
“Efeso (Collins) is hugely popular in large parts of Auckland, but the challenge is to get other voters, and to get his large base to come out and vote,” said Sinhalage-Fonseka.
That challenge is underlined by Auckland’s declining turnout for local body elections, hitting a record low of 35% in 2019. Otara, where Collins grew up, was the lowest of the low on 23%.
“Collins earlier was more of an underdog – getting the Labour nomination, to now anecdotally being the one to beat – he’s got the Labour machine etcetera.
“Wayne was initially scoffed at, but he’s outlasted Leo and Viv, and outdone Craig Lord – they may be evenly matched now,” she said.
Chris McKeen/Stuff
With the withdrawal of Viv Beck, Auckland’s mayoral race is shaping up as being between Collins and Brown. (File photo)
“Efeso has transformed from the underdog to be the institutional one to beat – Wayne’s story arc is that he’s outlasted two, won ‘the primaries’, to enter the final round.”
She said postal voting in local government elections was a “mind leap” involving having to find where to post or drop-off your paper, and one key motivation is that “people need to feel a candidate might not get in without their vote”.
Sinhalage-Fonseka pointed to upsets in both cities she previously worked in where Andrew King (Hamilton) and Andy Foster (Wellington) were “up against articulate, popular candidates”.
Voting in Auckland runs until midday October 8, but postal votes would need to be in the email a couple of days prior, and a network of drop-off points is being run by Auckland Council.



















Discussion about this post