PM should admit mistake regarding changed transcript over legal advice on Indigenous voice: Dutton
Paul Karp
The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, has gone on the offensive over changes to the transcript of a 2GB Radio interview with Anthony Albanese.
Guardian Australia revealed this morning that the transcript marked E&OE – meaning “errors and omissions excepted” – omitted a key part of an incorrect answer about legal advice on the voice referendum.
On Thursday, Dutton told 2GB Radio:
His office, as you will have seen, has changed the transcript where they’re now saying that he said something that he didn’t say or that he misrepresented the position – I don’t quite understand and I hope he can come out and clarify it today. But I think Australians deserve the information from our prime minister and he was looking tricky before yesterday and with a doctored transcript now he looks even more tricky.
Somebody has either shown some … bad initiative in the prime minister’s office, or he has instructed them to amend the transcript so that he can sort of whitewash history. Or he misspoke yesterday or misled: either way, as I say, there’s an integrity question here.
You know, we know the PM has got a bit of a glass jaw, but if he’s made a mistake, frankly, he should have picked the phone up to Ben Fordham or to your program this morning and said: ‘look, it’s just been brought to my attention. It’s a stuff up, it shouldn’t have happened. I’ve counselled the person that did it. I wasn’t aware of it.’
Or, if he’s now saying that there was legal advice but he forgot about the legal advice or thought it not convenient to mention it yesterday, then again, he should throw his hands up and say ‘I made a mistake’.
Key events
Filters BETA
Government MPs are continuing to comment on NZ PM Jacinda Ardern’s resignation.
Matt Thistlethwaite is the assistant minister for the republic.
My very best wishes to New Zealand’s Prime Minister @jacindaardern. Your commitment to making NZ and beyond a better place has been an inspiration. Australia thanks you for your exemplary leadership and friendship. pic.twitter.com/jlJQUKpESQ
— Matt Thistlethwaite (@MThistlethwaite) January 19, 2023
Audit uncovers some ‘shortfalls’ in telehealth rollout under Morrison government implementation
An audit has uncovered “shortfalls” in the rapid rollout of telehealth services under the Morrison government, AAP reports.
In response to the Covid-19 pandemic, the former federal government between March and May 2020 introduced 281 new telehealth items on the Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS).
A report by the auditor general released on Thursday found the expansion was “informed by largely robust policy advice and planning”:
However there were shortfalls in the governance, risk management and evaluation of the expansion.
The report found there was “no implementation plan for temporary telehealth … (and) the governance arrangements for the implementation of temporary telehealth involved inadequate assessment of the implementation and integrity risks”.
[The] health [department] did not plan for performance monitoring or evaluation of temporary or permanent telehealth.
Performance monitoring of the temporary telehealth expansion was limited and lacked measures and targets that could inform judgments about performance, and there was no evaluation that could assist with the design and implementation of potential expansions to telehealth during future emergency conditions.
Simon Birmingham also comments on Australian Dr Yang Hengjun’s detention in China
The shadow foreign affairs minister, Simon Birmingham, has also marked the four year anniversary of Dr Yang Hengjun’s detention in China.
The Australian writer has been charged with espionage by Chinese authorities.
Here’s part of Birmingham’s statement:
While reports have noted that Dr Yang was allowed a consular visit, the opposition remains deeply concerned for Dr Yang’s welfare, as well as his limitations on access to legal representation.
The uncertainty and continual delays to Dr Yang’s case are unacceptable and unjust.
We urge the Albanese government to use all available diplomatic means to secure the release of Dr Yang as well as Ms Cheng Lei, who was detained in August 2020.
Earlier today, the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong, said the Australian government was “deeply troubled” by ongoing delays in Hengjun’s case.
Not so safety beach
A jet ski rider who allegedly rode dangerously close to a boat at Safety Beach earlier this week will be charged by Water Police. Police allege the 16-year-old driver, who had only recently obtained his marine license, deliberately sprayed the people on the boat with water before speeding off.
Acting sergeant Michael Greenwood is not impressed:
We won’t tolerate dangerous behaviour on jet skis. The bay is a shared space – be mindful of others when using it.
If you engage in this type of behaviour, remember our strike teams are not far away. You will be caught up with.
A jet ski rider who allegedly rode dangerously close to a boat at Safety Beach this week will be charged by Water Police. It’s alleged the rider deliberately sprayed the occupants with water before speeding off.
Details ➡ https://t.co/xx8hExl7fY pic.twitter.com/r8rsLRjWLN
— Victoria Police (@VictoriaPolice) January 19, 2023
PM should admit mistake regarding changed transcript over legal advice on Indigenous voice: Dutton

Paul Karp
The opposition leader, Peter Dutton, has gone on the offensive over changes to the transcript of a 2GB Radio interview with Anthony Albanese.
Guardian Australia revealed this morning that the transcript marked E&OE – meaning “errors and omissions excepted” – omitted a key part of an incorrect answer about legal advice on the voice referendum.
On Thursday, Dutton told 2GB Radio:
His office, as you will have seen, has changed the transcript where they’re now saying that he said something that he didn’t say or that he misrepresented the position – I don’t quite understand and I hope he can come out and clarify it today. But I think Australians deserve the information from our prime minister and he was looking tricky before yesterday and with a doctored transcript now he looks even more tricky.
Somebody has either shown some … bad initiative in the prime minister’s office, or he has instructed them to amend the transcript so that he can sort of whitewash history. Or he misspoke yesterday or misled: either way, as I say, there’s an integrity question here.
You know, we know the PM has got a bit of a glass jaw, but if he’s made a mistake, frankly, he should have picked the phone up to Ben Fordham or to your program this morning and said: ‘look, it’s just been brought to my attention. It’s a stuff up, it shouldn’t have happened. I’ve counselled the person that did it. I wasn’t aware of it.’
Or, if he’s now saying that there was legal advice but he forgot about the legal advice or thought it not convenient to mention it yesterday, then again, he should throw his hands up and say ‘I made a mistake’.
Legendary New Zealand actor Sam Neill has weighed in on NZ PM Jacinda Ardern’s resignation. He says she was subject to a “disgraceful and embarrassing” pile on from bullies, misogynists and the aggrieved, and he doesn’t blame her for quitting.
#PrimeMinister @jacindaardern resigned today. I am not surprised nor do I blame her. Her treatment, the pile on, in the last few months has been disgraceful and embarrassing. All the bullies, the misogynists, the aggrieved. She deserved so much better. A great leader. Thanks PM! pic.twitter.com/7b1AhjBXrW
— Sam Neill (@TwoPaddocks) January 19, 2023

Eden Gillespie
Queensland counter-terrorism police have charged three men in relation to the displaying of neo-Nazi material, after conducting raids on three separate addresses across south-east Queensland.
Police told Guardian Australia that officers had discovered a number of offensive banners, stickers and flyers after executing search warrants on residential addresses in the Brisbane suburb of Toowong, and Gold Coast suburbs of Pimpama and Oxenford.

Emily Wind
Thanks everyone for joining me on the blog this morning, and what a morning it’s been! I’ll now hand over to my colleague Henry Belot who will see you through the afternoon news.
Panel appointed to review WA’s Covid management and response
The WA premier, Mark McGowan, has announced three independent experts have been appointed to review the state’s Covid-19 pandemic management and response, including a former WA health minister.
The former Liberal health minister John Day, emeritus professor Margaret Seares and the former ACCC deputy chair Michael Schaper will conduct a comprehensive review to inform future pandemic management and ensure that government arrangements are fit-for-purpose.
In a statement, McGowan said:
With the state of emergency now over, it’s critical that we take the opportunity to reflect on the lessons of the pandemic and provide learnings for future generations.
I have asked the independent and highly qualified reviewers to assess the best evidence and evaluate what worked, consider our preparedness for the future, and look at the economic, social and health outcomes of our response and management.
This was a once-in-a-hundred-year pandemic. My hope is that future governments will be able to rely on this review, our experience, and these lessons to protect our state and other jurisdictions from the next pandemic.

Peter Hannam
NSW miners reject ‘clumsy, politically-motivated’ coal market intervention
As we saw earlier, the NSW government is planning to require thermal coal miners in the state to set aside as much as 10% of their output for local use.
The intent, apparently, is to share the load among the miners so that firms currently not holding back supplies for the local market and exporting (at record prices) start sparing some for local users. These mainly include the four remaining coal-fired power stations.
Up to now, the mining industry has been rather quiet about the recent interventions, including the federal government’s price caps for black coal set in December for a year at $125 a tonne. That’s aimed at bringing down wholesale power prices (that eventually will help households and business users).
Anyway, the NSW Minerals Council has arced up at the coal reservation plans, announced by the energy minister, Matt Kean.
The council’s chief executive, Stephen Galilee, slammed the move as “a clumsy, politically-motivated market intervention designed in haste, with little or no consultation”:
The policy will have no meaningful impact on electricity prices, but will come at a significant economic cost.
He demanded Kean release all modelling and analysis undertaken to justify the move, including the expected impact on NSW energy prices and the relation to the coal price cap.
Galilee said:
Extending the policy to coal producers not currently involved in domestic coal supply is a radical change of approach that highlights how extremely rushed this policy process has been.
Risks included disrupting supply chains and also undermining the state’s reputation as an investment destination and trade partner, he said.
We suspect that’s not the last we’ll hear on this one.
The Queensland premier, Annastacia Palaszczuk, has shared an image of herself and the New Zealand PM, Jacinda Ardern, at the 2018 Gold Coast Commonwealth Games, after Ardern announced her resignation earlier today.

Christopher Knaus
Attorney general urged to drop prosecutions of whistleblowers Richard Boyle and David McBride
We reported a little earlier that the attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, will convene a roundtable with media outlets to work on press freedom reform and review Australia’s national security laws.
Dreyfus said the government was committed to accountability by the fourth estate and said:
Journalists should never face the prospect of being charged or even jailed just for doing their jobs.
Kieran Pender, a senior lawyer at the Human Rights Law Centre who has campaigned for whistleblower reform and whistleblower protections, has highlighted the government’s ongoing prosecutions of whistleblowers Richard Boyle and David McBride.
Pender has repeatedly urged Dreyfus to intervene in the cases, much like he did for the case against lawyer Bernard Collaery.
Pender said:
While I welcome the attorney general’s commitment to improving legal protections for press freedom in Australia, the ongoing prosecution of whistleblowers Richard Boyle & David McBride – who blew the whistle about government wrongdoing to journalists – is a stain on our democracy.
While I welcome the Attorney-General’s commitment to improving legal protections for press freedom in Australia, the ongoing prosecution of whistleblowers Richard Boyle & David McBride – who blew the whistle about government wrongdoing to journalists – is a stain on our democracy https://t.co/EWF3lXe48x
— Kieran Pender (@KieranHRLC) January 19, 2023
Dreyfus has flagged specific whistleblower and press freedom reforms will be pursued this year after the national anti-corruption commission legislation passed at the end of 2022.
Ministers meet Japanese delegation on cybersecurity and cooperation
The minister for home affairs, Clare O’Neil, and the assistant minister for foreign affairs, Tim Watts, today met with Japan’s Liberal Democratic Party delegation, who are visiting Australia, to discuss cybersecurity and opportunities for cooperation.
Watts took to social media earlier on to share some photos from the meeting:
O’Neil wrote of the meeting:
Learning from each other and [deepening] our cooperation in cyber security is vital to keeping us all safe online.
No sign of reported crocodile off Brisbane
Meanwhile, the mystery sighting of a three-metre saltwater crocodile off the coast of Brisbane – more than 400km south of its habitat range – is yet to be confirmed by authorities, AAP reports.
Queensland rangers have been looking for the marine reptile near Myora Springs on Stradbroke Island, also known as Minjerribah, after Quandamooka man Mark Jones spotted it while leading a kayak tour on Wednesday.
A Department of Environment and Science spokesman said:
The Queensland Parks and Wildlife Service has flown two experienced crocodile management wildlife officers from North Queensland to assist in the investigation.
If there is a crocodile, it would be in an area classified as an atypical habitat zone and removed regardless of its size under the state government’s management.
Crocodiles aren’t known to venture so far south in Queensland, with Minjerribah about 440km south of their regular habitat range. Bond University marine scientist Dr Daryl McPhee said if the animal was found, it would be “exceptionally rare” and a “one-in-one-hundred-year event”:
The person who reported it … is highly credible. He’s a local traditional owner but also somebody who’s spent a lot of time on the water, so I certainly put some credibility in what he’s seen.
It is feasible but obviously exceptionally rare for a crocodile to be this far south.
More reactions have come through this afternoon in response to New Zealand prime minister Jacinda Ardern’s resignation, first from Alicia Payne MP:
Shocked and saddened to hear that @jacindaardern is resigning.
“I hope I leave New Zealanders with a belief that you can be kind, but strong, empathetic but decisive, optimistic but focused”.
Indeed she has, not only in NZ but for people everywhere.
Thank you Jacinda. pic.twitter.com/WmD53LQyNe
— Alicia Payne MP (@AliciaPayneMP) January 19, 2023
Former leader of the Labor party, Bill Shorten, said Ardern was an “inspiration to women and men everywhere”.
Jacinda Arden reimagined New Zealand and its place in the world.
An inspiration to women and men everywhere, including those in my own life. pic.twitter.com/tAbPSm2oAT
— Bill Shorten (@billshortenmp) January 19, 2023
Ardern’s colleague in the NZ Labour party, Sarah Pallett, said working alongside Ardern was “one of the greatest privileges of [her] life”.
One of the greatest privileges of my life has been working in caucus with the extraordinary @jacindaardern.
She has redefined leadership to include empathy, compassion and kindness. Nobody could have given more, done more for NZ.
Thank you, boss, thank you for everything ❤️— Sarah Pallett – MP for Ilam (@sarah4ilam) January 19, 2023
Perrottet defends $5+ toll to use new M4-M8 Sydney motorway
Earlier today, the NSW premier, Dominic Perrottet, took to social media to share some photos of Sydney’s M4-M8 tunnels, due to open to motorists tomorrow morning two months ahead of schedule.
As reported by AAP, the state government defended a $5-plus toll to travel the 8km section of Sydney’s massive WestConnex motorway network.
Asked if that was too much for cash-strapped families to pay, Perrottet said drivers did not have to use the road:
I back in motorways 100%. Our government builds motorways. This is transforming our city for our people … Western Sydney are the big winners out of this project.
But ultimately, as well, you don’t have to use the road – everyone is a winner – if you don’t want to use the motorway you don’t have to.
After four years of construction, the M4-M8 tunnels will open to motorists tomorrow morning, 2 months ahead of schedule.
The new tunnels will save motorists up to 40 minutes between Western Sydney and Sydney Airport. pic.twitter.com/iy2RpfIVOS
— Dom Perrottet (@Dom_Perrottet) January 19, 2023
Passenger vehicles will pay $5.65 to use the new section of the tunnel, which is a distance-based calculation, capped at $10.47 across the entire tolled 22km network. Heavy vehicles, including trucks, will initially pay $16.95 to use the new section.
The new extension to the WestConnex motorway will open on Friday, two months ahead of schedule.
The 8km underground tunnel links the M4 motorway at Haberfield and the M8 at St Peters in Sydney’s inner west.
That means more time for you and less time stuck in traffic.
It was a momentous day cutting the ribbon on the completed tunnels, which form a major part of the WestConnex project. pic.twitter.com/9AX6q9Ve5V
— Dom Perrottet (@Dom_Perrottet) January 19, 2023
The tunnel will save motorists travelling from Western Sydney to the domestic and international airport at Mascot up to 40 minutes and bypass 52 traffic lights.
Want to have a sneak peek inside the new extensions of the M4 and M8? Come take a look around!
Filled with 360 tours and interviews with our in house team of experts, this is the preview you don’t want to miss!
Find out more here:https://t.co/gR3n7uJCSY pic.twitter.com/Qv3fvB81Ui
— WestConnex (@westconnex) December 8, 2022
Protesters spray-paint Woodside logo over Frederick McCubbin painting
Protesters have spray painted the Woodside logo over a painting at the Art Gallery of Western Australia.
The painting is Down on His Luck, the most famous work by Frederick McCubbin and arguably one of Australia’s most famous paintings.
The protesters are demanding no more industry at the Burrup Hub, Australia’s biggest new fossil fuel project.
Guardian reporter Joe Hinchliffe is on the ground in Tara, in Queensland’s western downs, where a shooting incident last night has stoked trauma for locals who are still reeling from last month’s murder of two police officers and a neighbour in nearby Wieambilla.
A store worker, who asked to remain anonymous, said she was half an hour from finishing her shift when she was abruptly told to go home:
I just seen heaps of police officers around, it was pretty scary. Very, very scary.
You can read his full report here:
WA’s McGowan set for trade trip to Japan, South Korea
West Australian Premier Mark McGowan will travel to Japan and South Korea next week to promote investment across a range of sectors, AAP reports.
The premier says the trip will focus on opportunities in tourism, education, medical research, biotech, space , defence, agriculture and renewable energy.
McGowan said:
Our relationships with Japan and South Korea are built on mutual respect and understanding and it’s important we continue to build those successful ties.
In Japan, the premier will meet representatives from various companies as well as government officials, including the governor of Tokyo and the governor of Hyogo prefecture. He will also speak at the 4th Clean Fuel Ammonia Association international symposium to promote WA’s hydrogen initiatives.
In South Korea, McGowan will visit Hyundai Motors’ fuel cell site, as well as meet representatives from the Korea Gas Corporation and Hyundai Steel.



















Discussion about this post