Last-ditch mediation
between Health NZ and the senior doctors’ union has
failed to avert an unprecedented 24-hour strike.
More
than 5000
members of the Association of Salaried Medical
Specialists are set to walk off the job on 1 May,
affecting about 4300 patients who will have their planned
treatment postponed.
Health NZ Te Whatu Ora deputy
chief executive Cath Cronin said the agency was “deeply
disappointed” that the union had refused to present its
latest offer to its members following mediation on
Thursday.
“We value our doctors and want to do the
best we can for them, but the reality is that Health NZ has
limited budget available for salary settlements within its
tight financial constraints,” she said.
Health NZ was
urgently applying for facilitation, which would “give an
independent party the opportunity to hear from both sides
and make a recommendation”.
“We believe we have been
fair and realistic, including offering to remove the lowest
pay steps for senior doctors.”
Cronin said Te Whatu
Ora had “heard” the union’s concern regarding growing and
retaining the senior doctor workforce.
Under Te Whatu
Ora’s new offer, a first-year specialist would receive a
$17,700 (9.5 percent) increase on base salary and a 9.5
percent increase on other remuneration, including KiwiSaver,
and another 6 percent the following year.
Advertisement – scroll to continue reading
A
second-year specialist would receive a $11,800 (6.2 percent)
pay increase on base salary plus 6.2 percent for KiwiSaver,
and another 6 percent increase in the following
year.
All other specialists would have their salaries
increased by 3 percent over two years, with a lump sum
payment of $8000 to doctors with three or more years’
experience.
“Additionally, we offered an incentive in
‘hard to recruit’ districts, which will assist in attracting
and retaining senior doctors.”
Latest offer ‘worse’ –
union
The Association of Salaried Medical Specialists
executive director Sarah Dalton said however there was no
point taking the offer to its members as for most of them it
was “worse than what was originally on the
table”.
Most specialists were already near or at the
top of the specialist scale, and for them the offer (a
33-month term with no backdating) worked out at “less than
0.77 percent on average”, she said.
Dalton said the
offer of less than 1 percent amounted to a pay cut in real
terms, and would “drive existing doctors away rather than
help retain them”.
It would not attract any new senior
doctors to fill vacancies, which run at 12 percent on
average, and up to 44 percent in some districts.
“New
Zealand will be short more than 3450 senior doctors by 2032
and we are already seeing the impact of doctor shortages
across the country with longer wait times in emergency
departments and for first specialists’
appointments.
“At the same time, Health NZ continues
to pay considerable amounts to locums [doctors covering
specialist vacancies] some of whom are left in the posts for
months rather than days or weeks, and who are paid
significantly more than salaried staff.
“So we think
their priorities are wrong, they’re not taking a long-term
investment approach. They still can’t adequately account for
where there are gaps and where there are not.”
While
Health NZ was claiming to have made “recruitment and
retention offers” in hard to staff areas, that was only
happening in four districts, she said.
“They have
coincidentally limited those to the four that have been in
the media the most. Some of them do have the greatest need,
like Tairāwhiti, but there are regions that have
demonstrably higher vacancy levels that have not been
included in this list.
“So they continue to ignore
their own data in terms of what they say they are
doing.”
Dalton acknowledged that Te Whatu Ora did move
to address some problems in mediation, including offering to
“restore relativities” with junior doctors.
That would
benefit about 500 members.
However, some doctors were
still waiting for aspects of the last collective settlement
to be implemented. For instance, some districts were still
not paying emergency department shift allowances.
“The
strike will result in planned procedures being postponed,
but the same number of procedures are lost every week due to
ongoing staff shortages,” Dalton said.
Health
Minister blames union
In a post on X, Health Minister
Simeon Brown blamed the union for rejecting what he called
“a credible offer” by Health NZ.
“By choosing to
strike, thousand of patients will have surgeries and
specialist appointments cancelled, a further delay in care
for patients who have already been waiting for too
long.”
Health NZ had estimated the strike would cause
the cancellations or delays for 4300 planned treatments and
specialist assessments, and up to the same number of
radiology procedures, he said.
“Health NZ presented a
credible offer in good faith as part of mediation last week.
This would have made a significant difference to the
remuneration of our senior doctors, and address key issues
in order to attract and retain senior doctors to our
workforce.
“ASMS have also decided not to put this
offer back to its members, which would have given senior
doctors the option to avoid union led strike action planned
for the 1st of May.”
That offer included a pay cost
for newly qualified specialists to ensure they earned more
than junior doctors and did not get a pay cut.
Health
NZ had also offered a lump sum payment of $8000 over two
years to specialists with three years’ experience or more,
and a two-year “recruitment and retention payment” of
$25,000 for those who agreed to move to “hard to staff”
regions like Nelson and Gisborne, Brown said.
“I call
on the union to return to the negotiating table rather than
undertaking strike action that will jeopardise the care of
thousands of patients.
“It is also not too late for
doctors to take control of this situation and direct their
union to get back to the negotiating table – strike action
which 52 percent of doctors did not vote
for.”
Hospitals and emergency departments will remain
open, and the union is working with Health NZ to ensure
life-preserving services continue during the
strike.
© Scoop Media




















Discussion about this post