• Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
No Result
View All Result
Subscribe Now
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
The Insight Post
  • Home
  • Insight
  • Blog
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Health
  • Politics
  • Shop
    • Gift Shop
    • Value Shop
    • Store
    • Bargain Shop
    • Discount
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Travel
  • USA
    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Mary Peltola Emerges Victorious in Alaska Senate Race, Making History for Democrats

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Stranded in Conflict: Palestinians Navigate the Tenuous Balance of War and Peace Amid Ceasefire Efforts

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Trump Administration Revokes Pay Increase for Head Start Educators

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Unexpected Triumph: Gay Candidates Achieve Unforeseen Victories in Challenging Races

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Microsoft Outlook Experiences Prolonged Outage Affecting Users Nationwide

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    Gunfire Erupts in D.C.: Authorities Search for Suspect Amid Rising Concerns Over Public Safety

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    LAUSD Takes Strong Action Against Hate Speech Following Racial Slur Incidents

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Beloved Former Los Angeles Times Columnist Steve Harvey Passes Away at 80

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

    Exploring Diversity: ‘Ten Lives’ Showcases the Varied Economic Journeys of Americans

  • Video
  • World
    • Asia
    • Africa
    • South America
    • North America
    • Europe
    • Oceania
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Oceania Australia New Zealand

‘Police f…ed it up, plain and simple’: Police refuse to release report into controversial murder investigation

by Theinsightpost
October 24, 2022
in New Zealand
0 0
0
‘Police f…ed it up, plain and simple’: Police refuse to release report into controversial murder investigation


Police are refusing to release a review of the controversial investigation into the murder of Upper Hutt woman Lois Tolley, sparking accusations they are covering up serious misconduct.

Tolley, 30, was shot point-blank in her home in December 2016, in what police described at the time as “an execution-type killing”.

After an extensive investigation, named Operation Archer, three men were eventually charged in 2019 with her murder.

But the charges against all three men, who have name suppression, were dropped by police last year, before the case went to trial, with a judge commenting, “there is presently really no evidence against any of them”.

READ MORE:
* ‘An abomination of an investigation’: How the Lois Tolley murder case collapsed
* Police: Top detective defends controversial CIPEM interviewing method
* Men formerly charged with murdering Lois Tolley keep name suppression
* Lois Tolley murder: Case against three men collapses

This followed revelations that one of the accused had falsely confessed to the murder, after police used a contentious interviewing technique, the Complex Investigation Phased Engagement Model (CIPEM).

High Court judge Simon France said the man, known as X, had been manipulated by the detectives interviewing him, who had broken numerous fundamental rules of interviewing, and X’s “confession” was flawed and not credible.

The case against the other two men collapsed for separate reasons, largely related to the unreliability of key witnesses – including a woman twice charged with perverting the course of justice, and jailhouse informants with numerous convictions for dishonesty, who told conflicting stories.

In a rare move, police subsequently appointed Auckland KC and former Crown prosecutor Aaron Perkins to undertake “an independent review of aspects of the police inquiry”.

The report of Aaron Perkins KC into Operation Archer is being kept from the public by police.

Lawrence Smith/Stuff

The report of Aaron Perkins KC into Operation Archer is being kept from the public by police.

However, police refused to release the terms of reference for Perkins’ review, making it unclear which parts of the failed investigation were being looked at, and whether he was considering why the case collapsed against all three defendants, or just X.

Perkins’ review was completed in August.

But police are now refusing to release the report, or even a summary of its findings, saying it is “confidential and legally privileged”.

Assistant commissioner Lauano Sue Schwalger said the review contained information that was “sensitive in nature. For that reason and due to the fact that the investigation into Ms Tolley’s death remains ongoing we will not (sic) commenting further as it could prejudice future work on this case.”

Lois Tolley’s mother, Cathrine MacDonald, said police had informed her of the review’s findings, and she supported the police, but was unable to comment further.

However, none of the former defendants, their families, or lawyers have been contacted by police or informed of the findings.

KEVIN STENT/STUFF

Lorraine Duffin visits a memorial to her niece Lois Tolley for the first time in 2018.

Wellington lawyer Lara Caris, who together with Val Nisbet represented one of the men accused of the murder, known as AB, said the case highlighted an array of questionable police tactics.

“I have grave concerns there appear to be a significant number of serious improprieties in the way this case has been investigated, and we’ll never get answers as to whether or not that’s correct, and who’s responsible for them.”

Caris said all the families involved deserved to know why the investigation into Tolley’s murder “has gone so catastrophically off track”.

“And to sweep it under the rug not only prevents justice and answers being provided in this case, it also opens up the prospect there won’t be any lessons learnt from this to ensure it doesn’t happen again.”

Given there had been no trial or appeal to expose what occurred, the public were left in the dark about why nobody had been convicted after nearly six years, in a very high profile murder, Caris said.

She pointed to other recently overturned convictions where there were major concerns about police tactics, including those of David Lyttle, Mauha Fawcett and Alan Hall.

“Somebody needs to be policing the police, and not releasing this report or allowing any assessment of it, allows them to essentially ensure they are judge, jury and executioner.”

Wellington lawyer Lara Caris, who defended one of the men charged with the murder of Lois Tolley.

Supplied

Wellington lawyer Lara Caris, who defended one of the men charged with the murder of Lois Tolley.

Caris had not been contacted by Perkins, and didn’t know whether he even considered issues like the use of unreliable covert informants by police during the investigation.

“If it was a comprehensive review, why won’t they just tell us? And the fact they won’t, makes you cynical as to what the answer is, doesn’t it?

“This was not an unsolvable case. But the police f…ed it up, plain and simple. It’s just not good enough.”

One of the men who had the murder charges against him withdrawn said the public needed to know someone could be arrested and spend two years in prison purely on the basis of claims by jailhouse snitches.

Even after the charges were dropped, he had suffered severe consequences due to being stained with the accusation of being a murderer.

Cathrine MacDonald, the mother of Lois Tolley, at a memorial seat for the murder victim in Harcourt Park, Upper Hutt.

Kevin Stent/Stuff

Cathrine MacDonald, the mother of Lois Tolley, at a memorial seat for the murder victim in Harcourt Park, Upper Hutt.

The lawyer for X, Robert Lithgow KC, said he understood police had announced the “so-called independent review” of Operation Archer, in order to assist public understanding of what went wrong.

“But they’ve clearly decided not to share whatever insights have been achieved.

“That begs the question whether New Zealand police understand anything other than winning and losing.

“Because that’s what we don’t know, isn’t it – have they had any learnings out of all this?”

Nicholas Wintour, the lawyer for the third man charged, CD, said Perkins’ report should be released, with information crucial to the ongoing investigation, redacted if necessary.

“It’s millions of dollars of taxpayers’ money, isn’t it, (spent on the murder investigation), and now they’re just covering it up.”

Wintour said during the investigation, police deliberately hid material from him until the last minute that suggested his client wasn’t involved in the murder.

Auckland lawyer Nicholas Wintour who represented one of the men charged with the murder of Lois Tolley and said he had never seen such skulduggery in an investigation in his career.

Supplied/Supplied

Auckland lawyer Nicholas Wintour who represented one of the men charged with the murder of Lois Tolley and said he had never seen such skulduggery in an investigation in his career.

“That’s so wrong. That’s not the country I want to live in.”

“Wintour believed police tried to fit evidence around the men they thought had committed the crime.

“It’s terrible stuff, it really is.”

A relative of one of the men charged has also called for police to stop hiding Perkins’ report.

“The police shouldn’t be above the law. The public have a right to know what happened.

“And police need to own what they’ve done, learn from it, and make sure it will never happen again.”

Detective Superintendent Tom Fitzgerald, the architect of the controversial CIPEM interviewing technique, was closely involved with controversial interviews of a man later ruled to have falsely confessed to murdering Lois Tolley.

Stacy Squires/Stuff

Detective Superintendent Tom Fitzgerald, the architect of the controversial CIPEM interviewing technique, was closely involved with controversial interviews of a man later ruled to have falsely confessed to murdering Lois Tolley.

The refusal to release the report follows continued efforts by police to withhold material relating to the Lois Tolley investigation, and the CIPEM interviewing method.

Stuff has twice been forced to get court judgments in order to obtain access to relevant documents.

It also comes after the retirement of the country’s top investigator and architect of CIPEM, Detective Superintendent Tom Fitzgerald, earlier this month.

Fitzgerald was closely involved with the interviews of X, but insisted CIPEM wasn’t to blame for mistakes made by the interviewing detectives, and said his retirement had nothing to do with scrutiny of the technique.

Aaron Perkins was contacted for comment.



Source link

ShareTweetSend
Previous Post

Henry Cavill confirms he’s returning as Superman

Next Post

Phil Simmons to step down as WI Men’s Head Coach

Related News

Hakeem Jeffries Makes History with Nomination as First Black House Speaker
New Zealand

Hakeem Jeffries Makes History with Nomination as First Black House Speaker

November 18, 2026
ThinkTV Launches Captivating New Podcast Series: The TV Paradox
New Zealand

ThinkTV Launches Captivating New Podcast Series: The TV Paradox

November 18, 2026
Te Whāriki Research Journey: From New Mexico to Rarotonga and Back to INIHKD
New Zealand

Te Whāriki Research Journey: From New Mexico to Rarotonga and Back to INIHKD

November 15, 2026
KBR Collaborative Media Agency Joins Forces with AIMA for Enhanced Industry Impact
New Zealand

KBR Collaborative Media Agency Joins Forces with AIMA for Enhanced Industry Impact

November 15, 2026
Next Post
Phil Simmons to step down as WI Men’s Head Coach

Phil Simmons to step down as WI Men’s Head Coach

Discussion about this post

Subscribe To Our Newsletters

    Customer Support


    1251 Wilcrest Drive
    Houston, Texas
    77042 USA
    Call-832.795.1420
    e-mail – news@theinsightpost.com

    Subscribe To Our Newsletters

      Categories

      • Africa
      • Africa-East
      • African Sports
      • American Sports
      • Arts
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • Business
      • Business Asia
      • Business- Africa
      • Canada
      • Defense
      • Education
      • Egypt
      • Energy
      • Entertainment
      • Europe
      • European Soccer
      • Finance
      • Germany
      • Ghana
      • Health
      • Insight
      • International
      • Investing
      • Japan
      • Latest Headlines
      • Life & Living
      • Markets
      • Mobile
      • Movies
      • New Zealand
      • Nigeria
      • Politics
      • Scholarships
      • Science
      • South Africa
      • South America
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • Travel-Africa
      • UK
      • USA
      • Weather
      • World
      No Result
      View All Result

      Recent News

      Jeff Bezos Reveals His Role in Selecting Robert Pattinson as James Bond, Sparking Online Buzz

      Jeff Bezos Reveals His Role in Selecting Robert Pattinson as James Bond, Sparking Online Buzz

      November 18, 2026
      Nicolas Cage Embraces Unique Pasta Diet to Channel NFL Legend for Upcoming ‘Madden’ Role

      Nicolas Cage Embraces Unique Pasta Diet to Channel NFL Legend for Upcoming ‘Madden’ Role

      November 18, 2026
      Ghana Actors’ Guild Leadership Conflict Escalates to High Court in Tema

      Ghana Actors’ Guild Leadership Conflict Escalates to High Court in Tema

      November 18, 2026
      Fulham Sets £50 Million Price Tag on Calvin Bassey as Manchester United Eyes Transfer

      Fulham Sets £50 Million Price Tag on Calvin Bassey as Manchester United Eyes Transfer

      November 18, 2026
      • Home
      • Advertise With Us
      • About Us
      • Corporate
      • Consumer Rewards
      • Forum
      • Privacy Policy
      • Social Trends

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In

      Add New Playlist

      We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

      You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in .

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Insight
      • Blog
      • Business
      • Entertainment
      • Health
      • Politics
      • Shop
        • Gift Shop
        • Value Shop
        • Store
        • Bargain Shop
        • Discount
      • Sports
      • Tech
      • Travel
      • USA
      • Video
      • World
        • Asia
        • Africa
        • South America
        • North America
        • Europe
        • Oceania

      Theinsightpost ©2026 | All Rights Reserved. Theinsightpost is an Elnegy LLC company, registered in Texas, USA

      The Insight Post
      Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

      Strictly Necessary Cookies

      Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

      Cookie Policy

      More information about our Cookie Policy