Sunak says changes to system should lead to ‘vast majority’ of asylum applications from Albanians being refused
Sunak says almost a third of asylum seekers are from Albania.
But it is a safe and prosperous country, he claims.
He says people will only be able to claim to be victims of modern slavery if there is evidence of this, not just a suspicion of this.
He says this, and other changes, should lead to “the vast majority” of claims from Albania being declared unfounded. People will then be returned quickly.
And he says he wants to ensure all Albanians in the backlog are quickly removed.
He says the government is also committed to starting flights to Rwanda, to send asylum seekers there (under the plan announced when Boris Johnson was PM).
Key events
Filters BETA
Adam Afriyie says he will not quit as Conservative MP after bankruptcy order
Adam Afriyie, the Conservative MP who has been declared bankrupt, says he is standing down at the next election, but will not quit parliament before then.
It is widely assumed that people declared bankrupt cannot serve in parliament. But that only applies when a bankruptcy restrictions order or a debt relief restrictions order is in place, and that does not seem to be the case here.
My colleague Jessica Elgot has the full story.
In an unrelated development – or perhaps not unrelated; Rishi Sunak is clearly hoping that Labour will vote against his proposed new asylum law next year, and that it will function as a wedge issue, with Keir Starmer on one side and a majority of voters on the other – the polling company Savanta has published the results of an MPR poll suggesting that Labour is on course for a 314-seat majority. Yes, that is right; not 314 seats, but a majority of 314.
MRP stands for multilevel regression and poststratification (MRP) and it is a polling method that takes conventional voting intention data and uses it to assess what might happen on a constituency by constituency basis by cross-referencing the demographic polling data with what is known about the demographic makeup of particular constituencies. Ever since an MRP poll suggested the Tories were on course to lose their majority in 2017, when conventional polling said the opposite, they have been taken very seriously.
But would the Tories really be reduced to just 69 seats, as the MRP model suggests? Savanta says:
The poll, Savanta’s first MRP since Labour conference and conducted in conjunction with Electoral Calculus, gives Labour a 20pt voting intention lead which, when converted to seats would more than double the number of MPs they currently have in Westminster.
The poll shows that the Conservative party would be likely wiped out in much of the north of England, with the model suggesting that the party would not hold a single seat north of Lincolnshire, while also losing all of the seats in London, and conceding many seats in the South West to Labour and the Liberal Democrats.
Martin Baxter, founder of Electoral Calculus, which worked with Savanta on the data, expresses caution. He says:
This is an interesting poll, because it is the first MRP we have done since the Conservatives slid so far behind Labour, and therefore we have very little to compare it with. MRP results are different to applying uniform national swing (UNS) to the 2019 general election baseline. The UNS prediction would give the Conservatives about 24 more seats than this model.
Previous elections suggests that MRP is usually more accurate than UNS predictions, but we are in uncharted electoral waters and uncertainty is higher than usual.
Rishi Sunak’s statement has now finished. He was on his feet for almost an hour and 40 minutes.
James Grundy (Con) asks Sunak if he agrees that MPs who claim there is no such thing as an illegal asylum seeker are wrong. Sunak agrees. He says illegal immigration is putting unsustainable pressure on local communities.
Amnesty International accuses Sunak of ‘scapegoating’ asylum seekers
Amnesty International UK says the PM’s statement shows that “he either doesn’t have a clue or frankly does not care”. In a statement Steve Valdez-Symonds, Amnesty’s refugee and migrants rights director, said:
Sunak speaks of fairness – yet his government has wrecked the UK’s asylum system, doing significant harm to thousands of vulnerable people for no reason other than an attempt to avoid the responsibilities he expects other countries to take.
Fairness means acting on our legal responsibilities, not shamelessly seeking to shirk them. It means respecting people’s rights and recognising their needs, not demonising people to excuse the cruel injustices the government is doing to them.
The announcement today is littered with errors of both law and fact, and if acted upon will make an already disastrous situation created by Sunak’s government’s policies more harmful to people fleeing conflict and persecution while continuing to profit smugglers, traffickers and other abusers.
Instead of scapegoating people seeking asylum, we urgently need the government to completely overhaul its policy, cancel the Rwanda deal, put in place safe routes so fewer desperate people risk their lives and focus on fairly and efficiently deciding the asylum claims the UK receives.
The statement did not specify what Sunak’s “errors” were, but I have asked Amnesty to elaborate, and will post a response when I get one.
Marco Longhi (Con) asks what Sunak will do if he is blocked by the courts?
Sunak says the new law will make it clear that people coming to the UK illegally will have no right to stay.
Again, he sidesteps the question about what he would do if a court were to rule this as being incompatible with the European convention on human rights, or any other treaty to which the UK is party.
Richard Fuller (Con) asks who will be accountable for ensuring these policies are delivered.
Sunak says people will want to see “flights leaving”, and people coming out of hotels, next year. There will be transparent metrics, he says.
Sunak sidesteps questions about whether his plan would require UK to derogate from refugee convention
Joanna Cherry (SNP) asked if the government was going to derogate from any international treaties to implement these plans. Sunak dodged the question. But Sir Edward Leigh (Con) has just said Cherry was right. He says the UK might have to derogate from the refugee convention. Will the UK do that?
Again, Sunak sidesteps the question. He just says he wants to see people removed who arrive in the UK illegally.
Sir Roger Gale (Con) told Rishi Sunak in the Commons that this problem would have to be resolved on a pan-European basis. Sunak said he agreed. He replied:
He is absolutely right, which is why it’s so crucial that in the last few weeks we have not only restarted the Calais Group of European nations meeting, which the home secretary deserves enormous credit for.
She has also put that group on a permanent basis, making sure that we now go further working with Frontex, the European border agency, working towards a UK-EU returns agreement for the first ever time and that is the path forward.
The best way to solve this problem is upstream, working with our allies in northern Europe, and the plans and progress that [Suella Braverman, the home secretary] has made are going to deliver exactly that.
Alison McGovern (Lab) says the backlog of asylum claims is 14 times as high as it was when Labour left office.
Sunak says it is half the size it was when Labour was in office.
Sunak was referring to the figures for the earlier years of the first decade of the century, when asylum applications to the UK were almost double what they are now. This graph, from a recent report from the Tony Blair Institute, highlights the trend.
What Sunak said about how he wants to ensure ‘vast majority’ of asylum claims from Albanians are rejected
And this is what Rishi Sunak told MPs about the new agreement with Albania, and the new process for dealing with asylum claims from Albanians. He said:
A third of all those arriving in small boats this year – almost 13,000 – are Albanian.
And yet Albania is a safe, prosperous European country.
It is deemed safe for returns by Germany, France, Italy, Sweden.
It is an EU accession country, a Nato ally and a member of the same treaty against trafficking as the United Kingdom.
The prime minister of Albania has himself said there is no reason why we cannot return Albanian asylum seekers immediately.
Last year Germany, France, Sweden all rejected almost 100% of Albanian asylum claims. Yet our rejection rate is just 45%.
That must not continue. So today I can announce a new agreement with Albania – and a new approach.
First, we will embed Border Force officers in Tirana airport for the first time ever, helping to disrupt organised crime and stop people coming here illegally.
Second, we will issue new guidance for our case workers and make it crystal clear that Albania is a safe country.
Third, one of the reasons we struggle to remove people is because they unfairly exploit our modern slavery system.
So we will significantly raise the threshold someone has to meet to be considered a modern slave.
For the first time, we will actually require a case worker to have objective evidence of modern slavery rather than just a suspicion.
Fourth, we have sought and received formal assurances from Albania confirming they will protect genuine victims and people at risk of re-trafficking, allowing us to detain and return people to Albania with confidence and in line with ECAT [European Communities against Trafficking].
As a result of these changes, the vast majority of claims from Albanians can simply be declared “clearly unfounded”.
And those individuals can be swiftly returned.
Lastly, we will change how we process Albanian illegal migrants, with a new dedicated unit expediting cases within weeks, staffed by 400 new specialists.
Over the coming months, thousands of Albanians will be returned home.
And we’ll keep going with weekly flights until all the Albanians in our backlog have been removed.
What Sunak said about five immediate measures being taken to deal with small boats
This is what Rishi Sunak said about the five measures being implemented without legislation to reduce small boat numbers.
Our policing of the channel has been too fragmented, with different people, doing different things, being pulled in different directions.
So we will establish a new, permanent, unified Small Boats Operational Command.
This will bring together our military, our civilian capabilities, and the National Crime Agency.
It will coordinate our intelligence, interception, processing, and enforcement.
And use all available technology, including drones for reconnaissance and surveillance, to pick people up and identify and then prosecute more gang-led boat pilots.
We’re adding more than 700 new staff and also doubling the funding given to the NCA for tackling organised immigration crime in Europe.
These extra resources will free up immigration officers to go back to enforcement which, will in turn, will allow us to increase raids on illegal working by 50%.
And it’s frankly absurd that today illegal migrants can get bank accounts which help them live and work here. So we will re-start data sharing to stop this.
It’s unfair and appalling that we are spending £5.5 million every day on using hotels to house asylum seekers.
We must end this.
So, we will shortly bring forward a range of alternative sites such as disused holiday parks, former student halls, and surplus military sites.
We have already identified locations that could accommodate 10,000 people and are in active discussions to secure these and many more.
Our aim is to add thousands of places through this type of accommodation in the coming months – at half the cost of hotels.
At the same time, as we consulted on over the summe, the cheapest and fairest way to solve this problem is for all local authorities to take their fair share of asylum seekers in the private rental sector.
And we will work to achieve this as quickly as possible.
We need to process claims in days or weeks, not months or years.
So we will double the number of asylum caseworkers.
And we are radically re-engineering the end-to-end process with shorter guidance, fewer interviews, less paperwork and introducing specialist case workers by nationality.
We will also remove the gold plating in our modern slavery system, including by reducing the cooling off period from 45 to 30 days – the legal minimum set out in the ECAT Treaty.
As a result of all these changes, we will triple the productivity of our case workers, and we expect to abolish the backlog of initial asylum decisions by the end of next year.
As a result of these changes, the vast majority of claims from Albanians can simply be declared “clearly unfounded”.
And those individuals can be swiftly returned.
I will post more on the details of this agreement in a moment.



















Discussion about this post