Secrets of Survival and Mysterious Extinction on Wrangel Island

Reassessing Extinction Theories

“We can now confidently reject the idea that the population was simply too small and that they were doomed to go extinct for genetic reasons,” says senior author Love Dalén, an evolutionary geneticist at the Centre for Palaeogenetics, a joint collaboration between the Swedish Museum of Natural History and Stockholm University. “This means it was probably just some random event that killed them off, and if that random event hadn’t happened, then we would still have mammoths today.”

Love Dalén. Credit: Ian Watts

Insights for Current Conservation Efforts

In addition to shedding light on woolly mammoth population dynamics, this analysis of Wrangel Island mammoths could help inform conservation strategies for present-day endangered animals.

“Mammoths are an excellent system for understanding the ongoing biodiversity crisis and what happens from a genetic point of view when a species goes through a population bottleneck because they mirror the fate of a lot of present-day populations,” says first author Marianne Dehasque of the Centre for Palaeogenetics.

Marianne Dehasque working in the Ancient DNA Lab. Credit: Love Dalén

Genetic Challenges and Enduring Legacy

To understand the genomic consequences of the Wrangel Island bottleneck on the mammoth population, the team analyzed the genomes of 21 woolly mammoths—14 from Wrangel Island, and 7 from the mainland population that predated the bottleneck. Altogether, the samples spanned the last 50,000 years of the woolly mammoth’s existence, providing a window into how mammoth genetic diversity changed through time.

Compared to their mainland ancestors, the Wrangel Island mammoth genomes showed signs of inbreeding and low genetic diversity. In addition to overall low genetic diversity, they showed reduced diversity in the major histocompatibility complex, a group of genes known to play a critical role in the vertebrate immune response.

Wrangel Island tusk. Credit: Love Dalén

Long-Term Genetic Impacts and Future Research

The researchers showed that the population’s genetic diversity continued to decline throughout the 6,000 years that the mammoths inhabited Wrangel Island, though at a very slow pace, suggesting that the population size was stable up until the very end. And although the island’s mammoth population gradually accumulated moderately harmful mutations throughout its 6,000-year tenure, the researchers showed that the population was slowly purging the most harmful mutations.

“If an individual has an extremely harmful mutation, it’s basically not viable, so those mutations gradually disappeared from the population over time, but on the other hand, we see that the mammoths were accumulating mildly harmful mutations almost up until they went extinct,” says Dehasque. “It’s important for present-day conservation programs to keep in mind that it’s not enough to get the population up to a decent size again; you also have to actively and genetically monitor it because these genomic effects can last for over 6,000 years.”

The Final Mystery of Woolly Mammoth Extinction

Though the mammoth genomes analyzed in this study straddle a large timespan, they do not include the final 300 years of the species’ existence. However, the researchers have unearthed fossils from the mammoth’s final period and plan to conduct genomic sequencing in the future.

“What happened at the end is a bit of a mystery still—we don’t know why they went extinct after having been more or less fine for 6,000 years, but we think it was something sudden,” says Dalén. “I would say there is still hope to figure out why they went extinct, but no promises.”

Reference: “Temporal dynamics of woolly mammoth genome erosion prior to extinction” 27 June 2024, Cell.
DOI: 10.1016/j.cell.2024.05.033