Now, at 20, she is back in the digital world.
“It’s constant access again,” Ms. Shub said. “It’s the relief of knowing I can do things easier. I got Instagram, too, and it’s been nice reconnecting with people on it.
“But then you get used to it all, is the problem,” she continued. “I feel like I’m not trying as hard anymore. When I had the flip phone, I had to put in effort to get to places, to talk to people. Everything was a task. Now it’s easy to do things. I guess I still don’t like needing the crutch of a smartphone, though I couldn’t figure out how to go on without one.”
I asked what she thought of “Into the Wild” these days.
“I still think that book is amazing,” she said. “I feel the same way about it. I still believe phones are a big problem. I’m always aware now, when I’m hanging out with people, how everyone is just looking at their phone. It’s an epidemic. It’s sad, really.”
She added: “My life is just in a different place than it was in high school. It sucks I got back into this head space, and maybe I’ll go back to a flip phone one day, but I need the smartphone for now.”
While many original Luddites have been navigating campus life, Ms. Butler, a high school senior, has become a leader of the club’s New York presence. Seated at the library table with a worn copy of Adrian Nicole LeBlanc’s “Random Family,” she provided a report.
The club had died out at Murrow, she said, shortly after it found itself in the media glare — the attention had obliterated its street cred. But now a new Luddite chapter, with Ms. Butler at the head, is thriving at Brooklyn Tech. To recruit new members, she sits at a table at school fairs next to a poster that reads, “The Truth Will Set You Free.”



















Discussion about this post