Emma Grant, who debuted with the Collingwood Magpies in 2017 and retired from AFL in 2020, is now suing Collingwood Football Club for negligence.
Grant claims the club failed in their duty of care for her after she suffered a concussion that forced a premature end to her career.
Over her four years with the Magpies, Grant played a total of 20 games after showing much promise after her initial drafting.
In one of her first practice matches, Grant played each quarter in a different position. She would later be known for her versatility, starting her career as a forward but eventually playing both in midfield and defence.
In January 2020, during a preseason practice match, Grant suffered a severe concussion. She was subsequently unable to play the rest of the season and two months later announced her retirement.
Only 30 years old at the time, Grant said, “In the end I made the decision to put my health first.”
In the same media release, the club said: “A debilitating and prolonged recovery from concussion did not allow her to again pull the black and white jumper on.”
Grant has now launched civil action against the club.
According to legal documents, Grant suffered a head injury on January 18 2020 and was allowed to return to training again on February 5, only two and a half weeks later.
This decision, according to Grant’s legal representatives, “fell below a reasonable standard of care” and as a result, the plaintiff has “suffered injury, loss and damage”.
Grant’s case is not isolated and it seems that Australia is only now catching up to the consequences of putting its athletes at risk by exposing them to concussive injury.
An ongoing Senate inquiry, which includes four of the nation’s sporting codes – the National Rugby League, Rugby Australia, Boxing Australia and Football Australia – is currently taking place in Canberra.
The inquiry has delved extensively into the dangers and risks around concussion injuries.
“Australia in many ways is addicted to contact sport,” researcher Stephen Townsend said at the inquiry. “We love it even though it kills us.”
The inquiry has put a spotlight on Australia’s historically proven love of contact sport and our relationship with the risks that come with it. Our nation’s legacy of sport has possibly overshadowed the negative consequences that it can have on our athletes.
Sport in our country, as described by Townsend, is ultimately “too culturally and economically important to change.”
Collingwood’s Emma Grant is tackled during a 2018 AFLW match. (Photo by Michael Dodge/Getty Images)
The daughter of rugby league legend Steve Folkes also came forward to address the Senate, detailing her personal account of the affects that concussive damage had on her father.
Folkes, who played 245 games for the Canterbury Bulldogs and represented NSW in State of Origin nine times, became the first NRL player to be diagnosed with chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE). CTE is a degenerative brain disease believed to be brought on by repeated blows to the head, as is common in combat sports such as boxing.
Head and concussive injury, however, is just as prevalent in both Aussie Rules and rugby league, and is incurred not only in games but frequently in training.
The culture around athletes not reporting injuries to their coaches or not detecting the symptoms or recognising a concussion seems to be commonplace across all combat and contact sports.
There is a clear need for coaches and institutions to properly educate not only themselves but the athletes in their care around the long-term risks they are subjecting themselves to through their sport. In addition, it seems that safe practices to better offset the damage of concussive injury are still lacking.
The same law firm representing Grant has also announced that a class action is being planned against the AFL, similar to the class actions brought against the NFL by American footballers that resulted in a $1 billion settlement.
The firm intends to pursue the class action on behalf of potentially hundreds of players in the AFL and AFLW.
The firm’s managing principal, Michel Margalit, said, “the cost of Australian society receiving so much joy from the game is the obligation to care for our players. The time has come for change and to do what is right.”


















Discussion about this post